Tooltips for "topic admin actions"

So, it seems that PR linked above didn’t quite make it, but then there was a second PR which got merged :smiley:!

https://github.com/discourse/discourse/pull/7146

… and then reverted :sob:

The reverting logic is explained by @codinghorror like this:

I don’t think this should be merged @sam it’s a LOT of extra copy that has to be translated and most of it adds little value over the words that are already there… these tooltips will hardly ever be seen and they add almost nothing. My vote is that this gets rolled back.

and commented-on by @sam like this:

I will roll back for now … but some of the tooltips are handy

  1. What does “archive” do? hover on archive to figure out
  2. What does “reset bump” do?
  3. What does “unlisting” do?

I think the failure here is that the change was too far reaching.

As for myself, I’m on my honeymoon with Discourse, I’m a new admin, and I went looking for this feature also.

It’s true that these tooltips have to be translated and that they will rarely be seen, but I don’t feel it’s true that they don’t bring much value.

My rationale is this: Topic admin actions are things with consequences - you can annoy users, you can make content disappear, you can generate email notifications. I feel the need for extra security before clicking these. Some of these concepts are new to me.

I would vote (recommend? ask?) that this (or something like this) actually gets into the product. I would focus the copy on a logic of “explain consequences, if any, especially if they are irreversible or impact others; provide security to a noobie admin operating this menu”.

Thanks!

1 Like