Can we have an Edit Log please?

A list of all edits viewable by Admin (perhaps sortable by member).

I think this would be useful for some very good reasons:

  • Help keep a lookout for edit-spam
  • Help see which members are being helpful (those adding tags, re-categorising Topics, editing titles, etc) (and so to see who would make good moderators)
  • Help ensure workload between Mods is equal

What should be logged?

Perhaps…

  • Post edits
  • Title edits
  • Re-categorisation of Topics
  • Appending/editing of tags
  • Post deletions

Maybe if time allows (or this proves a success), go further, and add logs for:

  • Topics that have been pinned/unpinned
  • Wikis (made/unmade)
  • Anything else that would allow an admin to quickly overview what’s been going on on the forum

I think this would be very useful for large companies/busy admins in particular :slight_smile:

This is usually handled by reducing the editing grace period (defaults to 5 minutes / 300 seconds) and post edit time limit (defaults to 60 days / 86400 minutes) in the site settings. I see absolutely no reason for a bunch of other custom features when those site settings control it perfectly.

Also note that thanks to @gerhard people who flagged a post to threshold are now notified when the flagged post was edited.

1개의 좋아요

Not sure what you mean Jeff - how is it handled when they have 60 days to come back and edit their older posts and nobody is notified of such edits?

Our edit period is 12 hours and they sneak in even with that. But edit spam was just one aspect - being able to see who’s regularly doing housekeeping tasks around the forum would be incredibly handy.

2개의 좋아요

Set it to 1 day, or even lower, as needed. That’s my point.

Couldn’t this be a data explorer query? Grab the last months worth of edit history?

Not sure I understand why this should be a full blown feature

5개의 좋아요

Even that is too low and too much of an inconvenience for genuine users - they shouldn’t have to suffer. As I mentioned though, edit spam is just one aspect. Having these kind of logs makes it super easy for Admins to get an overview of which members are ‘helping out’ i.e potential mod material.

I hadn’t seen the data explorer plugin, however I still think this is one of those features that once you have, you would find difficult to live without (if you have a busy or relatively busy forum) particularly if it is expanded to have a similar (configurable) page for moderators.

1개의 좋아요

There could be a page somewhere that shows all recent edits, I suppose.. we could put pr-welcome on this as needed.

7개의 좋아요

Don’t we have a report or data explorer query that shows this now?

Yes, confirmed, there is the “post edits” report on your admin dashboard on the reports tab.

There might be an equivalent in Data Explorer too @rishabh?

3개의 좋아요

Yes, we ship a query with the Data Explorer that targets recent edits made by TL0/TL1 users. It’s right here:

7개의 좋아요

여기에 사용자가 작성한 게시글 수정 횟수를 나타내는 한 줄을 추가할 수 있습니다

게시글 수정: 20

여기서 20은 클릭 시 게시글 목록으로 연결되거나, 게시글로 연결되는 링크가 포함된 모달이 팝업으로 열립니다. 게시글 수정 이력을 보기 위한 별도의 UI를 구축하고 싶지는 않으며, 게시글로 직접 연결하는 링크만 제공하면 충분할 것 같습니다.

5개의 좋아요

다시 한번 이 문제가 수정되었습니다. 적어도 이 특정 문제는 해결되었죠. Discourse 팀이 직접 수정한 건지, 아니면 PR을 통해 반영된 건지는 정확히 알 수 없지만, 어쨌든 수정이 적용되어 있습니다.

1개의 좋아요