I just realized that i can’t go back to the original topic when following a link without post number. To illustrate: https://meta.discourse.org/t/welcome-to-meta-discourse-org/1 https://meta.discourse.org/t/welcome-to-meta-discourse-org/ Is this a bug or not possible by design?

Yes please, keep the slug and the id: For example https://meta.discourse.org/t/cant-navigate-back-when-using-urls-without-post-number/197060 That way the link will remain stable. Also this will work but it is not as pretty imo and will cause a redirect. https://meta.discourse.org/t/-/197060

I would say this is an edge case, it was reported before. Our ember router and discourse server router are in slight disagreement about what to do here. Relying on slug that is ever changing for routing a topic is super fragile anyway. If we rename “welcome to meta discourse org” to “welcome to me…

Ok, thanks! So if I want internal back and forth to work, I actually need to keep both slug and id? Because using just the id seems not to work: https://meta.discourse.org/t/1

Can't navigate back when using urls without post number

Support

manuel (Manuel Kostka) July 14, 2021, 2:02am 5

Ah ok, so I just need any slug and the right id, as in t/welcome/1
Thanks for clarifying

Topic		Replies	Views
Clicking an internal link with slug only and no topic ID should create a history entry Bug	7	1518	July 22, 2021
Removing title from URL breaks links Support	24	2592	July 2, 2019
Using slug only as url without id Support	3	801	December 25, 2020
Incomplete topic titles beginning with a number can have odd behavior Support	5	1346	June 5, 2020
Permanent route to posts Feature	2	128	July 24, 2025

Can't navigate back when using urls without post number

Related topics