yes, I have been using Don’s version for some months and really like it. I think when a brand new user lands on the site, it can be a little overwhelming, they have no idea what they are looking at. Hiding the sidebar makes the UI a little less confusing. By my way of thinking, once someone visits the site many times they know where to look for the menu when they need it.
Thank you very much. I tried to give you a thumbs up but messed it up by clicking the heart too much, and ended up having to wait “54 seconds”! Hence this short message.
I can see the appeal of having the sidebar closed by default, especially on smaller screens where every bit of space helps. Maybe making it a user preference (or remembering the last state) would be the best compromise, since some people rely on the sidebar constantly while others rarely use it.
Thanks @nathank for creating a topic for this theme component!
I think something like this should work nowadays. This approach will only close the sidebar on the initial load, and after that, it will fall back to the default behavior (remembering the user’s preference).