The Gated Topics in Category theme component, officially maintained by the Discourse team, allows site admins to display a login prompt overlay on topics within specific categories or tags. This feature is designed to encourage user registration or group joining by restricting content visibility to non-members. Key configuration settings include enabling specific categories or tags (defaulting to ‘gated’) and defining required groups. Customizable text labels for headings and call-to-action buttons allow for tailored messaging. Community members jrgong and patrickemin expressed strong enthusiasm for the tool’s potential to convert organic traffic into members. However, digitaldominica raised questions about trust-level-based gating, while Tiago_santos requested customizable signup URLs.
Technical discussions highlighted limitations and bugs. David_Ghost and Jagster debated SEO implications, with RGJ suggesting the Category Lockdown plugin as an alternative for better crawler support. A critical security concern was raised by REALITY and agemo: disabling JavaScript allows users to bypass the gate and view content, a vulnerability also applicable to bots and scrapers. nathank noted that robust protection would require a formal plugin rather than a frontend theme component.
Functional issues were also reported. patrickemin experienced temporary failures, which Moin could not reproduce, eventually leading patrickemin to switch to the Guest Gate component. Additionally, eisammy identified a visual bug where profile avatars were misaligned on desktop. This was quickly addressed by awesomerobot, who merged a template modernization update to fix the avatar positioning. Other users, such as agemo and MachineScholar, proposed features like partial content previews and stricter granularity to enhance the “fear of missing out” strategy for subscriptions.
Gated Topics in Category allows site admins to show a login prompt that covers the topic contents in specific categories or tags to encourage readers to signup/log in or join a group.
Thank you for this, its more than useful because i have daily almost 80-120 000 pageviews trough organic traffic but barely new members, this is gonna change it!
Hi is it possible to set a trust level for this component? So instead of signing up I would get users to reach level 2 before viewing the content. As i’m trying to avoid users just registering for free and not participating in the forum growth overall.
Can you share an example where it does not work? The preview on the theme creator works fine for me, and on the forums that are linked in your profile, it seems to work as well.
Thanks for testing, it seems I made a confusion between viewing a list and viewing a topic, this component does not prevent viewing a list and topics excerpts, it only prevents viewing threads is it?