I’m a bit confused as to how the visibility of automatic groups works. At this point, I am just talking about the /groups directory. Here is what I am seeing in a pretty fresh install of 2.7.0.beta4: If an user with admin or moderator bits looks at /groups, they see all 8 automatic groups (admin…

[图片] mdoggydog: Is this how it is supposed to work? Or is there something wrong with the handling of the Visibility parameters for these groups? There is a comment in the code that explains what is going on: “hide automatic groups from all non stuff to de-clutter page.” That happens here: dis…

[图片] simon: What the code is doing is overriding the group visibility settings for automatic groups when the groups page is viewed by a non-staff users. Well, that does explain it. And I’m sure that code was written with the best intentions, but it is broken because: Maybe I want other aut…

Also: this “lets-just-hide-the-automatic-groups-on-the-Groups-catalog-despite-the-visibility-setting” behavior is bad because it obscures the other aspects of visibility_level that are still meaningful. E.g., Admin X tries out visibility settings and realizes that non-staff users cannot see trus…

Hi mdoggydog :slight_smile: Some points seem valid to me, such as: [图片] mdoggydog: The management interface for automatic groups does allow me to set the visibility of non-Moderator automatic groups, but this setting is ignored. Which is confusing. I invite you to create a feature topic wi…

[图片] Coin-coin le Canapin: I invite you to create a Feature topic with your suggestions Done! [图片] Respect the visibility settings of all automatic groups Feature (One person’s feature request is another person’s bug report… upside_down_face) The “Grou…

自动组的可见性如何工作？

支持

Canapin (Coin-coin le Canapin) 2023 年9 月 28 日 07:50 6

你好 mdoggydog

有些观点对我来说是有效的，例如：

这很令人困惑。

我邀请你创建一个#feature 主题来分享你的建议

话题		回复	浏览量
Cannot change member_visibility_level of automatic groups Bug groups	10	587	2024 年1 月 20 日
Respect the visibility settings of all automatic groups Feature groups	14	787	2023 年10 月 23 日
Help with automatic group restriction Support	8	353	2024 年3 月 20 日
Admin.groups.manage.membership.automatic not replaced UX groups	14	178	2024 年12 月 9 日
Trust Level groups are not shown on group list even if they are set to be UX trust-levels , groups	3	84	2025 年11 月 25 日

自动组的可见性如何工作？

相关话题