Introducing nested replies

On my forum, I don’t see a “view as flat” option like in the example screenshot.

For me, I need flat as the global default, with nested being an optional view that users can use when they want to, with flat always being readily available.

As long as it’s a “view as nested” button which people can toggle back off, this would be great. A per-user setting to switch to nested as the default would also be great as long as they can switch individual topics or all topics back to flat at will.

Without adequate controls to toggle between views, I’ll have to stick to flat.

2 Likes

I actually completely removed the view as flat option. It was around for our internal testing so we could compare flat vs nested view easily. We saw no value in keep it around so it’s now gone.

3 Likes

I might be imagining this but when the nested replies are selected the width appears to narrow on a full screen browser :

It doesnt appear to be related to Modernize Foundation theme as I have disabled and re-enabled this

1 Like

You are not imagining things.

The width is larger because it is taking up more room due to the fact that the timeline has been removed.

2 Likes

Of course! That makes so much sense! I just couldnt put my finger on what had changed!

2 Likes

it’s finally supported​:clap:

Reddit-style UI is good, but I see another design like:

- A: ...
    - B: ...
    - C → B: ...
    - D → C: ...

In China, this pattern is used by almost all forums / social media platforms. It also collapses all nested posts except for the first one. I think it can avoid distracting and can be an option

1 Like

This can be achieved by setting Nested replies max depth lower (default is 10) and enabling Nested replies cap nesting depth. Give that a try

1 Like

Hello,
I find this feature really great, greatly improving the readability of a conversation.
However, though I may have missed a setting, I have two remarks:

  • When a reply is moderated, a high-level user (moderator, admin, etc.) no longer sees the moderated messages (automatically or not) grayed out. They appear normally. The grayed-out mode for these messages is a real plus for quickly identifying them.

  • When I reply to a conversation, a filter hides the formatting bar of the reply, also hiding the option to attach an image, for example:

1 Like

Thanks for the reports. Got a PR to fix the first issue. I believe the second issue is already fixed if you rebuild.