All three of the following links are to the second post in this topic. However, only the first two work. The third one worked until very recently, and we use it pretty extensively in our community to avoid cluttering wiki posts that reference several posts within the topic. That third link now just …

What you’re actually using there is a hack, especially if it is a deep link to a specific post. This is the correct permalink URL form https://meta.discourse.org/t/{title}/{topic-id}/{post-id} This has been hacked up to work, when people accidentally omit the topic ID, we guess that if the “topic …

The third link does work if you open it in a new tab. It’s only when you click within one tab that it breaks. And it breaks bad - you can’t even click the logo to go back to the front page of the forum. TypeError: Cannot read property 'get' of undefined at n.setupController (application-779d3dc…

Yep, it’s being treated like a permalink redirect and they’re not supported for internal links.

[תמונה] codinghorror: I recommend not relying on sort of hacky undocumented behaviors, though, and switching to this formally supported form Unfortunately we had no way of knowing that this wasn’t officially supported behavior. As far as we were concerned, it worked. So we used it. I’ll try t…

You can search your posts for URLs which match a regex. AFAIK you just need to specify anything in the title field, it doesn’t need to be the title but does have to pass something in.

You can specify anything for the title, yes. It’s not as simple as finding my posts though. It has become common practice in a portion of our community to remove the title entirely to avoid the verbose urls. So several users would have to fix all of their links. Why was this moved to support? Havin…

Because it’s something you need to fix due to unintended use, it was never a supportable thing. A bug is a feature of function that stopped working, which isn’t the case here. I’ve also updated the title to reflect what actually happened here, links aren’t created without a title, this has arisen b…

[תמונה] Stephen: You can identify every broken link in one hit by looking through your database, your users don’t need to go back and fix them by hand I’m not an admin, so unfortunately I can’t do this. [תמונה] Stephen: A bug is a feature of function that stopped working, which isn’t the…

That wouldn’t fix your problem though, right?

Removing title from URL breaks links

תמיכה

seanblue 27 ביוני,‏ 2019,‏ 3:29am 2

Second post to demonstrate the bug.

נושא		תגובות	צפיות
Incomplete topic titles beginning with a number can have odd behavior Support	5	1345	5 ביוני,‏ 2020
Clicking an internal link with slug only and no topic ID should create a history entry Bug	7	1503	22 ביולי,‏ 2021
Edit URL into a topic title after creation? Feature	17	3522	10 במאי,‏ 2020
Removing the /2, /3, /4, etc links for each reply within a topic URL Development seo	33	4317	13 באוקטובר,‏ 2024
`Topic#featured_link` containing more than just a valid URL Bug	4	839	4 בדצמבר,‏ 2017

Removing title from URL breaks links

נושאים קשורים