Putting this here instead of a bug since I’m not sure how to repro at the moment or what the exact issue is… In any case, some of my users noted in that Discourse wasn’t tracking a particular topic for them, even though it should have been since they had all replied to it (and had kept that setting…

Hi @Yuun , a push has been fixed for this issue, it should resolve your issue if it was related to the kind of issue we had with the categories, can’t be 100% sure as I couldn’t reproduce it, please let me know if you have other reports of this issue.

(Possible) Intermittent issues with topic tracking status

Support

zogstrip September 13, 2017, 3:06pm 2

Could this be related to this?

2 Likes

Topic		Replies	Views
Editing category settings causes category to be muted for the current user Bug	6	1089	May 18, 2018
Setting a category's notifications to "tracking" not working as expected? Bug	10	712	April 1, 2022
Ignore auto-track settings if topic is in muted category Feature	5	1100	August 22, 2016
New topics in muted categories do not appear in latest list? Support	9	70	September 22, 2024
Muted topic is completely hidden Support	11	2017	January 9, 2023

(Possible) Intermittent issues with topic tracking status

Related topics