At bitcoincashresearch.org we are looking to offer a certain level of decentralization of the forum, including the possibility that anyone who considers it necessary could rebuild a given instance of the forum in another domain. For that to be possible, we should publish DB’s backups periodically. …

That’s a pretty wacky edge case! Do you’d want to remove IPs and email addresses? Without email addresses, there would be no way for users to reclaim their accounts (if they used a password, they could log in, but then they would not be able to put their email address back in, as there would be no …

Here are public SQL dumps of a Discourse forum: Index: if-archive/info/intficforum You could get some ideas from there.

I agree that it could seem like a wacky edge case. But the idea behind it doesn’t seem so much since it works towards avoiding forum’s centralization. I understand that this may not be very important for some forums, but it may be for others. I also agree that removing users and passwords (among o…

I would like to add some context. There is a very specific need / use case. There is an operational discourse that has important content and the content will become more important over time. Because of the nature of the ecosystem that uses it, avoiding central points of failure is something we have…

Also these changes are obviously very non-trivial. It would be good to hear feedback, issues and alternatives. Maybe resources can be pulled together on our ecosystem side to create a fork that implements the idea.

[图片] emergent_reasons: Therefore I think what Leandro needs is a feature in discourse that allows users to login through cryptographic challenges rather than traditional account/password schemes. That can be done by adding support for webauthn as a passwordless authentication method like expl…

That’s another solution to login. Oh, and regular users don’t have to approve email address changes if they’re logged in, so a dump with email addresses removed would be ok for all users who should log in using whatever credentials are in the database (password is the easiest). A plugin that eithe…

@Falco and @pfaffman thanks a lot for your feedback and advice. We will investigate Webauthn to see if we can follow that path, same for your plugin @pfaffman . I will get back to you in a couple of days with some comments, questions, or conclusions.

Another possibility on the horizon is the use of a Augmented PAKE (Password-Authenticated Key Exchange), so that the password is both practically unrecoverable from the database and never touches the wire. Unfortunately, they’re all still solidly in the realm of experimental cryptography, and not r…

If you want to keep the email/password login, but in a way that anyone can enter the account of any user in the backup’ed database, you may achieve that generating an email based on the username for every user, like <username>@email.invalid. For passwords and logins, assuming that discourse uses en…

发布数据库备份而不暴露用户隐私信息

支持

Falco (Falco) 2021 年1 月 26 日 03:00 7

这可以通过添加对 WebAuthn 作为无密码认证方式的支持来实现，正如 WebAuthn 支持中所解释的那样。

此外，还需要一项服务来清理备份文件中您不想暴露的字段。

话题		回复	浏览量
What to do if your Discourse is compromised Self-Hosting reference	0	10376	2016 年2 月 24 日
Restore backup to a local instance in a safe/anonymized way Support	10	1043	2021 年5 月 22 日
Archiving the public data of a forum Support	3	1889	2019 年3 月 17 日
How to encrypt the email addresses for compliance with privacy and PII laws? Feature privacy	4	1844	2015 年2 月 12 日
Create, download, and restore a backup of your Discourse database Self-Hosting backups , how-to	25	24491	2026 年5 月 29 日

发布数据库备份而不暴露用户隐私信息

相关话题