Redirects not working as expected

I have a _redirects file sitting in the site/static with the following content:

/analytics/*	  200!	Role=admin
/analytics/*	/index.html	301!
/leaderboards/*   200!	Role=user,admin
/leaderboards/* /index.html	301!

Currently whenever I hit one of those urls, regardless of if I’m logged in through Identity (as admin) or not, I get kicked back to root. Oddly enough this issue isn’t persistent - sometimes the role redirects work properly, sometimes they don’t. Every time I modify _redirects this issue has a chance of appearing again. I’m sure I’m doing something wrong so I appreciate any help!