Reordering categories and setting fixed category positions - not working

The procedure for reordering categories as they appear on the landing page for logged in users, as set out in the documentation here, seems not to be working.

I am unsure whether this is likely due to a recent beta update, or some related setting I recently and unwittingly played with, but would much appreciate any suggustion to get category display ordering priorities working again.

Per the posted procedure, I have enabled fixed category positions and fixed category positions on create and have assigned numeric priorities such that my most preferred category appears above my less preferred category in the reorder categories dialog, and I have clicked the save button.

Clearing the browser cache, closing and reopening my browser, logging back in (as administrator), and checking the category order showing in the reorder categories dialog shows the settings were indeed saved - however still posts from the less preferred category always display first, completely filling the landing page display by default when the site is first opened by a logged in user - even though it has much less recent posts than the preferred category, and much less activity generally.

As a result, anyone visiting the site/checking in would conclude at a glance that nothing much has happened there for a long time - unless they happen to be one of the very few who are up to speed with the way posts are organized by Discourse into categories, and that they would first need to click on a different category heading in the left sidebar, in order to see anything recent that is relevant to them.

לייק 1

The landing page (/latest) for logged-in users always shows topics sorted by recent activity, not by category order or priority. If you want your preferred categories to appear first, you can switch the default landing page to something like /categories instead of /latest. That way, users will see your prioritized category order on the homepage, and when they click into a category, its topics and posts will be shown accordingly.

לייק 1

… except for me that doesn’t seem to be happening.

Only old posts from the least important category are appearing on the first page - the posts in the most important /higher priority category are newer, but are nevertheless being hidden by default

This was not the case a couple of weeks ago.

I want to ensure a curated experience for logged in users who are not invested enough to learn the ins & outs of Discourse navigation, but just want to see the most recent posts, in the most relevant category, right there when they first click on the site link.

By any chance is your preferred category added under default categories muted in the site settings? If it’s muted, its posts won’t appear on /latest even when they’re newer. Could you please check and confirm?

לייק 1

thanks @jahan_gagan .

By way of explaining my setup, in case this helps:

The two categories in question are called ‘Architects Forum, and ‘Open Forum’, both of which are actually subcategories, each sitting within its own corresponding master category

‘Architects Forum is a subcategory of ‘PRIVATE’ master category, and ‘Open Forum’ is a subcategory of the ‘PUBLIC’ master category.

The idea is in future to add further subcategories within these master categories, as the need arises

The PUBLIC vs PRIVATE master categories were used as a way to align front facing content discussed with the login access level.
As you can see above, I have other subcategories and master categories in place, but these have little to no activity.

Those with forum accounts can see and post to subcategories within the ‘PRIVATE’ master category (though currently only one subcategory is in active use) - it is expected that these subcategories may sometimes contain somewhat sensitive discussion, not intended for wider distribution.

Meanwhile everyone, with or without an account, can see and post to subcategories within the ‘PUBLIC’ master category.

By far the most activity currently occurs within the ‘PRIVATE > Architects Forum’ subcategory, and it is thus the latest posts in this subcategory that I want to appear for logged in users by default.

Instead, no matter what I do, the landing page now shows old posts in the ‘PUBLIC > Open Forum’ category.

There is not supposed to be anything posted directly to the master categories themselves, and to reduce the scope for this (as this kept happening), both master categories were set to ‘muted’, so the option to post to them directly was hidden.

As a test, I have tried clearing that default_categories_muted setting, so that nothing is muted, but this seems to make no difference to what shows up on the landing page by default - when opening the site, even after hitting <Ctrl+F5> in browser - the site now aways defaults to ‘PUBLIC > Open Forum’ category posts only

How are you testing this? Are you impersonating another user? Did you make sure that user has access to the private category? It sounds a silly question, but could be an oversight?

I got another logged in user to send me a screenshot

EDIT I also just made a test account and signed in with that - again no change