# האם עלינו להפסיק לנסות לטפח את הקהילה הווירטואלית הזו?

**URL:** <https://meta.discourse.org/t/should-we-stop-trying-to-nurture-this-virtual-community/201170>\
**Category:** Community Building\
**Created:** [20 באוגוסט,‏ 2021,‏ 6:10pm UTC](https://meta.discourse.org/t/should-we-stop-trying-to-nurture-this-virtual-community/201170 "2021-08-20T18:10:25Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Showing post:** 5

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Johani](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/meta/user_avatar/meta.discourse.org/johani/32/176920_2.png) [@Johani](https://meta.discourse.org/u/Johani)\
**Post date:** [21 באוגוסט,‏ 2021,‏ 6:11pm UTC](https://meta.discourse.org/t/should-we-stop-trying-to-nurture-this-virtual-community/201170/5 "2021-08-21T18:11:22Z")

</div>

Hey @nicopace 👋

The fact that you took the time to post this means that you’re committed. That’s the biggest pitfall any community can have - admins who are **not** committed.

So, it’s great that we don’t have to deal with that here.

> [@nicopace](#):
>
> Although we’ve done many concrete actions, we have done a review of the last 2 years of the platform, and although we know it has become useful, we feel we might have failed in promoting a healthy community.

Looking through the list of the things you’ve already done. I would say you’ve done pretty much everything that you can do.

However, the world is changing… and the average internet user is changing as well.

So, let’s look at that list from a 2021 perspective - and I’ll keep it short.

> [@nicopace](#):
>
> including our newsletter production workflow within the forum, so we make sure news get to them the earliest, and also to drive them back to the forum when they check the newsletter (manual written here: [APC CN Newsletter management manual - HackMD](https://hackmd.io/@nicopace/APC-CN-newsletter-manual) ):
> 
> - a selection of the responses in here: [Community networks on the web - #203 - Community Networks](https://communitynetworks.group/t/community-networks-on-the-web/278/203)
> - ends up in here: [Community Networks and Local Access Monthly Newsletter | Association for Progressive Communications](https://www.apc.org/en/community-networks-and-local-access-monthly-newsletter)

You’re relying too much on the “newsletter” mode.

For example:

[https://communitynetworks.group/t/community-networks-on-the-web/278](https://communitynetworks.group/t/community-networks-on-the-web/278)

I just scrolled through that topic, and I saw things related to India and also things related to Colombia in the same topic.

As a user, this makes it a lot more difficult for me to engage - because it’s a topic that covers a wide variety of subjects.

**I would recommend limiting topics to the discussion of a singular idea. That way, ideas can branch out and still be relevant to the main discussion.**

> [@nicopace](#):
>
> Running live events and using the forum for RSVP, live note-taking and pre, during and post interaction in between audience and speakers.
> 
> - some examples here:
> - [Education and Community Networks, Building Opportunities - #21 - Tech Talks - Community Networks](https://communitynetworks.group/t/education-and-community-networks-building-opportunities/557/21)
> - [Mobile telephony CNs in the global South - #30 - Tech Talks - Community Networks](https://communitynetworks.group/t/mobile-telephony-cns-in-the-global-south/511/30)
> - [Lightning Talks sessions about Community Networks Technology - #21 - Tech Talks - Community Networks](https://communitynetworks.group/t/lightning-talks-sessions-about-community-networks-technology/611/21)

It’s great that you have those talks documented and the transcripts available, but if you want to attract a bigger audience, it’s just too much visible text.

**Keep the video visible, put the transcript in a `<details>` tag like so**

> **transcript**
>
> ```plaintext
> This is my transcript.
> 
> ```

And add engaging questions below - like

How do you feel about XYZ?

Trust me, I’m lord-writes-alot, so I understand, but I also only do it when I know the audience will get it.

If you’re trying to grow your audience. A wall of text will never be beneficial.

Also, highlighting a post with `moderator-highlight` should be reserved to when you - as an admin/moderator - are giving a warning or really highlighting something. If I see a topic with 7 posts highlighted, I’d be hesitant to engage.

**don’t use `moderator-highlight` so much.**

> [@nicopace](#):
>
> and the upcoming ones:
> 
> - [Asia lightning talks: meet projects selected to strengthen community networks - Tech Talks - Community Networks](https://communitynetworks.group/t/asia-lightning-talks-meet-projects-selected-to-strengthen-community-networks/634)
> - [Africa lightning talks: meet projects selected to strengthen community networks - Tech Talks - Community Networks](https://communitynetworks.group/t/africa-lightning-talks-meet-projects-selected-to-strengthen-community-networks/636)
> - [Latin America lightning talks: meet projects selected to strengthen community networks - Tech Talks - Community Networks](https://communitynetworks.group/t/latin-america-lightning-talks-meet-projects-selected-to-strengthen-community-networks/638)

In this topic

[https://communitynetworks.group/t/asia-lightning-talks-meet-projects-selected-to-strengthen-community-networks/634/2](https://communitynetworks.group/t/asia-lightning-talks-meet-projects-selected-to-strengthen-community-networks/634/2)

I see that you guys added a poll.

Giving users options is a fantastic idea. However, giving users options too early is detrimental.

I’ll explain. If you have a topic with a poll that only 4 users vote on… any new users that land in your community will think it’s a ghost town. So, they won’t bother with creating a new account.

**Once you have an interactive userbase, feel free to create polls. Until then, it’s you directing where the community should head next.**

 ![image](https://global.discourse-cdn.com/meta/original/3X/d/5/d506448295a4034367292384dd5f6f178c716cc6.png)

To me, these are the numbers you should focus on most.

There’s nothing wrong with having “community-exclusive” content to drive people to your forum - which also relates to this.

> [@JimPas](#):
>
> If these two companies “maintain” the communitynetworks.group, why don’t they have any mention of it on either of their websites? Rhizomatica doesn’t have a link to it on their resource page or on their About page. Nothing at all. When I checked out [apc.org](http://apc.org) it was the same thing - no mention whatsoever of the communitynetworks.group. That to me is a little strange. One would think they would promote it or at the least give it some visibility on their sites.

And this is also a very valid point.

> [@manuel](#):
>
> the forum feels visually more or less characterless

A few category icons and a little bit of theming (we have many free configurable themes in the #Customization > Theme category) might also help.

**So, make sure the community is linked where relevant, spruce up the design a little bit, and add more content that attracts new users and makes existing users want to come back.**

---

_[View the full topic](https://meta.discourse.org/t/should-we-stop-trying-to-nurture-this-virtual-community/201170)._
