# האם עלינו להפסיק לנסות לטפח את הקהילה הווירטואלית הזו?

**URL:** <https://meta.discourse.org/t/should-we-stop-trying-to-nurture-this-virtual-community/201170>\
**Category:** Community Building\
**Created:** [20 באוגוסט,‏ 2021,‏ 6:10pm UTC](https://meta.discourse.org/t/should-we-stop-trying-to-nurture-this-virtual-community/201170 "2021-08-20T18:10:25Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Showing post:** 8

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![nicopace](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/meta/user_avatar/meta.discourse.org/nicopace/32/214950_2.png) [@nicopace](https://meta.discourse.org/u/nicopace)\
**Post date:** [3 בספטמבר,‏ 2021,‏ 12:42pm UTC](https://meta.discourse.org/t/should-we-stop-trying-to-nurture-this-virtual-community/201170/8 "2021-09-03T12:42:59Z")

</div>

Really thanks for so many insights!

> [@manuel](#):
>
> A design/ux feedback from browsing about 15 mins: the forum feels visually more or less characterless, but both _maintainers_ have a strong visual identity. That leaves the impression it’s the unwanted stepchild of both.

> [@JimPas](#):
>
> If these two companies “maintain” the communitynetworks.group, why don’t they have any mention of it on either of their websites?

> [@JonathanShaw](#):
>
> It’s particularly important that the platform is engaging for new users at first glance.

Thanks for this! It indeed feels a little left behind.

> [@manuel](#):
>
> Rhizomatica claims to be all about supporting community, but the site doesn’t offer easy ways to connect. The “Get involved” button leads to a 404 error page.

Indeed we ourselves haven’t properly communicated the existance and relevance of it.

> [@manuel](#):
>
> why doesn’t Rhizomatica embrace this forum as their own? Wouldn’t it just fit in their organizational model to have a community forum that offers easy and transparent ways to get involved and exchange knowledge?

This project has grown in its own silo… it is a very on-point question you rise! Thanks

> [@JimPas](#):
>
> Just from what you’ve written about the community’s accomplishments shows it has been a powerful tool.

Thanks! We believe that the current usecases are strong and don’t expect to stop exploring them, but curious how to keep exploring it (and learning with you all at the same time).

> [@Johani](#):
>
> I would recommend limiting topics to the discussion of a singular idea. That way, ideas can branch out and still be relevant to the main discussion.

The way it was structured made sense from a systems perspective (as it is connected to a newsletter producing tool that uses the RSS feed of the topics to digest news), but it didn’t made sense from UX. I will adjust it, thanks!

> [@Johani](#):
>
> Keep the video visible, put the transcript in a `<details>` tag

never thought about this, but makes sense!

> [@Johani](#):
>
> add engaging questions below

I think we’ve again made it so interactions happen mostly in the chat of the webinar, and not designed the interaction in the forum (and focused in the archival/discovery of it). More thought should be put on the UX.

> [@Johani](#):
>
> Once you have an interactive userbase, feel free to create polls. Until then, it’s you directing where the community should head next.

Makes sense, thanks for this!

> [@Johani](#):
>
> add more content that attracts new users and makes existing users want to come back.

This is in-line with conversations we’ve had, related to it your own home-cooked food 🙂

> [@JonathanShaw](#):
>
> a successful community is really hard to achieve if you don’t have a huge audience of your own already

There is a stagnant but growing community of community network practitioners, users, deployers, technicians, policy advocates… so the audience is there.

> [@JonathanShaw](#):
>
> What I’m doing is focusing my attention quite tightly on a couple of key use cases for the platform. In my case it’s wiki pages and help-wanted volunteer requests. When I talk to people about the platform, I will principally tell them it’s for these purposes, and I will make sure it is optimised for them.

It is related to what i’ve been trying with the newsletter and the webinars… maybe more attention to that would make it more relevant, and those usecases could drive its growth.

> [@JonathanShaw](#):
>
> So what key use cases could you start to make happen?

I think the webinars and the news discussion can be the center for now… and grow to other usecases as we go.

> [@HAWK](#):
>
> **In order for a community to succeed it has to solve a problem for people.**

I strongly agree… and believe there are a few elements there that the space could be useful for.

> [@HAWK](#):
>
> what success means for you

For all the groups of people mentioned earlier (implementors, advocates, technicians) to relate to the platform and for it to be the first place were they think of when they have a question about community networks. (i think!)

> [@HAWK](#):
>
> I’d work that out first and then I’d sample a small handful of the community and talk to them directly

Good suggestion!

**Action points** :

1. work on the UX of the homepage so users feel welcomed to read and to ask
2. add clear indications of the existance and relevance of the forum in each partner’s websites
3. modify newsletter integration so it works with topics in a category instead of responses on a topic.
4. in webinars, put the transcript in a `<details>` tag so it gets hidden by default
5. don’t use `moderator-highlight` so much.
6. Once you have an interactive userbase, feel free to create polls. Until then, it’s you directing where the community should head next.
7. add more content that attracts new users and makes existing users want to come back.
8. sample a small handful of the community and talk to them directly

---

_[View the full topic](https://meta.discourse.org/t/should-we-stop-trying-to-nurture-this-virtual-community/201170)._
