TL4s posting in archived topics

There is some confusion in the several discussions of archived topics.

Maybe the following points might clarify the conceptual space and how Discourse archiving appears to fit within it:

1. The ability to edit archives in Discourse is by-design for TL4 and up. It is not a mistake or omission.

Contrast this with the frozen in carbonite statement from 2015 which clearly does not match the reality of the Discourse archive feature.

It is unfortunate that that post persists in quote after quote. It sounds and looks good but it sets an unrealistic expectation that nothing will ever change in an archive. That has never been the case in the real world where information can always be added or amended for archived items.

2. In general, there are two key characteristic of archives: stored and unpublished

  • they are preserved for posterity because they have some desired value.
  • they are transferred to and stored in an “unpublished” state.

Conceptually, there is a clear distinction between using libraries to access published items and using archives to access unpublished items.

This distinction is breaking down in real usage due to archives increasing their use of electronic catalogs and digital imaging of items. This means that archive items or their reproductions are increasingly accessible through library systems.

That is much the same situation in Discourse where archived topics remain listed but don’t appear in all lists. Unlisting a topic makes it more like a traditional archive item requiring additional effort to find it in a segregated silo.

3. We interact with archive topics in Discourse function much like we handle archive items in real life.

We can access the archive zone (room, locker, shelf, folder, file, …) and we can access any item to add to it, annotate or tag it, loan it, and remove it e.g. to destroy it.

So it is not normal in the real world to unarchive an item to make such changes except when destroying it or otherwise permanently removing it from the collection.

Here’s the reason why. In the real world changing status involves physical effort so we would not do it unless the status change is permanent, e.g. move box out of storage to different building, delete catalog entry and update indexes, stamp box as removed from archive so it doesn’t accidentally get returned.

In the digital world it is effortless to change the status of an archive item. It is feasible to implement that logic but it diminishes the usefulness of the term archive.