Similar to some bugs before, if you look at the post count given in the linking box of a post, it gives the post #. However, this doesn’t match the numbers displayed in the navigation bar on the right. I think this topic may demonstrate the problem: Migrate a phpBB3 forum to Discourse - #580 by ge…

[图片] TallTrees: critical/paranoid members who somehow imagine something terrible going on right, but this is not a software problem with Discourse, just reassure your users that it’s normal and carry on. There is 0.0% chance we will be changing this behavior.

Okay - if that’s the case on that topic, please check a topic with whispers (or whisper here then post a test reply?) because you will have the same effect. Unfortunately this bug has been noticed on my forums by critical/paranoid members who somehow imagine something terrible going on :frowning:

How do you envision this working? Post numbers are assigned when the post is created, (they get the next available number) and cannot be changed after the fact, as this would break references/links to a specific post. Whispers are just a post in the topic that has a permanent “Staff Only” flag. Li…

The post # should match the post number computed in the scroll bar and thus ‘skip’ the whispers for non-mods. Linking to whisper posts could still be supported, but perhaps using a slightly different URL format e.g. /topicid/w-postid where the ‘w’ prefix denotes the postid is a whisper. [图片] Sa…

[图片] TallTrees: The post # should match the post number computed in the scroll bar and thus ‘skip’ the whispers for non-mods. Linking to whisper posts could still be supported, but perhaps using a slightly different URL format e.g. /topicid/w-postid where the ‘w’ prefix denotes the postid is a w…

[图片] Falco: If your community don’t like that whispers can be used, turning those off with the setting enable whispers may help. That still wouldn’t change the fact that the counts would be off if there were deleted posts in the topic. They’d still be wary/paranoid over the discrepancy… and y…

Community issues aside, I still think it should be simple enough to fix the most obvious mismatch in counts: [image]

[图片] TallTrees: I still think it should be simple enough to fix Famous last words :rofl: If we ignore whispers on the post permalink, how would admins link to whispers? Then we need to add a new URL format for whispers, like you proposed [图片] TallTrees: Linking to whisper posts could st…

My last post was requesting just the ‘cosmetic’ fixup of the post # mismatching the count, as shown in the screen shot - you said all the other stuff was a lot of work for little benefit, so I dropped it.

This is a problem that has stuck around for years, and a few attempts have been made to improve it and this is where we ended up. I’m of the opinion that it’s a combination of necessary transparency and not-going-to-be-noticed. (Yes, that’s a partial contradiction.) We aren’t willing to compromise…

[图片] riking: aren’t willing to compromise on the position of displaying posts in order (such as how large platforms like Twitter are handling the deleted posts issue). Would you be willing to expand or link to reference on what twitter is doing? I’m not a tweeter, so have no reference to comp…

帖子编号中的窃窃私语回复泄露

支持

TallTrees 2021 年1 月 18 日 17:04 8

撇开社区问题不谈，我仍然认为修复最明显的计数不匹配应该足够简单：

话题		回复	浏览量
Post URLs different from Post numbers Support	7	551	2020 年9 月 14 日
Toggle Whisper :eye: Theme component whispers	41	3615	2025 年6 月 25 日
Unfortunately I had to pull the plug Community Building	98	11765	2022 年12 月 24 日
Post number on slider disagrees with post Support	12	930	2023 年1 月 13 日
Questions about moving an existing forum to Discourse Community Building	23	3109	2021 年11 月 23 日

帖子编号中的窃窃私语回复泄露

相关话题