Why is it intentionally opaque as to when new topics can be created? Not clear whether posts or just ‘reading’ is needed… and why do you enable abusive bans by not even providing rationales and not even making it clear what happened, just a logging out? Honestly, all this and more makes this forum s…

Hello and welcome @whywhy :slight_smile: As Discourse Trust Levels are customisable, different sites can have different abilities and thresholds for each. I think our defaults are relatively easy to understand, but not every site will stick to those defaults and will tailor them to suit their own c…

It’s civilised discourse to let accounts be ‘disappeared’, practically, without any rationales whatsoever? Discord does the same thing (maybe it’s all those that begin with ‘dis’…) and I think it’s the worst online practice. By the way, it’s the opposite of ideal… I just gave up and posted some irr…

We would tend to recommend Anonymisation over deletion as it can leave holes in the conversation that would make disjointed reading for those coming to the topic later on. Though we also like to provide a range of tools to allow communities to effectively moderate themselves according to their own g…

I was trying to create a thread on another forum, not here, but thought of discussing these software aspects as, literally, every time I encounter this software on some site I always anticipate this inevitable annoyance, and wouldn’t mind if developers truly reflect on whether the above experience i…

The admins on that forum made it that way. Almost anything can be changed by the admins to make the forum as good as it can be in their eyes. This is something to contact the admins of that forum about instead of meta. You can find an email on the about page of that forum (<forum URL>/about)

Point is that this seems to be the software’s default (it might not be, but the question remains, why should it even at all encourage irrelevant posts?) - and most people go with defaults, and so the question then is: why is such an awful experience as above the default?

[圖片] whywhy: but the question remains, why should it even at all encourage irrelevant posts? How does this software encourage irrelevant posts? By default, as a new user, you can start 3 topics. Since the default requirements for the next trust level can be accomplished within ten minutes of…

As far as I know, on many sites I seem to want to post on, at least, I can’t even create a single post upon registration, which is why I assume irrelevant posts are needed (I tried just waiting, but nothing happened, and then the level changed as soon as I posted…)

Most likely is that the settings on those site were set to only allow new topics be created by members at trust level 1 or 2. The default setting is trust level 0 for that. This doesn’t mean that irrelevant posts are necessary, just that reply posts to established topics are required first before a…

Which would mean the posts are irrelevant, to the threads that are forced to have them due to this weird system… and it might not be the default, but for some reason it seems to happen most often with this forum software (some others might have made the unbelievably idiotic decision to pre-approve e…

为什么发帖前无法创建主题？

支持

Moin 2023年十二月19日 21:13 8

这个软件是如何鼓励不相关帖子的？

默认情况下，作为新用户，您可以发起 3 个主题。由于下一个信任级别（trust level）的默认要求可以在阅读十分钟内完成，我认为这个默认设置还不错。

話題		回覆	觀看
Should Discourse require reading to gain initial trust? Site feedback	41	10097	2016年四月30日
Understanding Discourse Trust Levels Blog trust-levels	119	93057	2026年八月29日
Difficulty interacting with Discourse as a new user via email Support	5	2044	2017年五月19日
Visually Disable Features that aren't Available at a Given Trust Level Support	3	1011	2017年十一月14日
Is it possible to limit TL0 to posting in one category? Feature	18	557	2026年五月7日

为什么发帖前无法创建主题？

相關主題