Share link in new post / reply / message?

AI-generated summary

In a discussion titled ‘Share link in new post / reply / message?’, jpreston asks whether it would be useful to allow sharing a post as a reply in another thread or as a private message, while noting ethical concerns about sharing private messages as public threads. HAWK clarifies that topics can already be converted to private messages and vice versa. merefield explains that this functionality is accessible via the Composer’s top-left icon, though it’s not intuitive — a point echoed by tobiaseigen, who admits to never noticing it despite years of use. jpreston wonders if users would prefer forwarding posts via message rather than inviting others to a topic, suggesting a distinction between on-site and off-site interactions may be valuable. merefield confirms forwarding is possible by selecting ‘New message’ and entering a recipient’s username. codinghorror defends the feature as a ‘power user’ tool, comparing it to keyboard shortcuts — useful but not meant for everyone. merefield agrees it’s extremely useful, while codinghorror and merefield acknowledge that while powerful, such features shouldn’t be front-and-center for new users to avoid confusion.

Hi all,

So I noticed there is the link to share a post/reply as a linked topic, and in messages its possible to share a message as a message and maybe change the recipients. I was wondering if it would be useful to do other combinations like:

  • share a post as a reply in another thread (instead of starting a new thread) (I guess you would just link it into the body of your reply though?)
  • share a post as a private message
  • share a private message as a thread (probably not, it is not necessarily fair to allow one party to invalidate the secrecy of both parties, ethical issue)

Thanks! :slightly_smiling_face:

1 Like

You can currently convert topics to PMs and vice versa. Is that what you mean?

3 Likes

Maybe, I can’t seem to find this though, I don’t have the option in any of the ‘Share’ buttons, is it somewhere else, or maybe requires higher trust level?

It’s in the Composer, the top left icon is a button which serves a short menu:

It’s not immediately obvious, though, I agree - intuitively you might think it would be a button on the bottom of a post, specifically the sharing button.

3 Likes

Ah thanks for that I understand now! I’m in the dark theme at the moment, and I didn’t notice the icon was a button. Also, I generated the feedback when I was in the share button just looking around. Probably a user who wanted to reply in a message would hit reply instead of share.

What if you wanted to forward the post to someone as a message? Would people do that rather than invite someone to the topic?

Maybe keeping the distinction between off-site and on-site interactions is useful?

whoa! I have been using discourse for years and never noticed this feature. thanks! :seedling:

4 Likes

Choose New message and enter the username of the third party

3 Likes

Which kind of proves my point about how intuitive this is :wink:

1 Like

It’s a power user feature, like keyboard shortcuts. Why would that be surprising? Keyboard shortcuts aren’t “intuitive” either, but that’s hardly the point, now is it..

3 Likes

There’s no doubt it’s an extremely useful feature

1 Like

So is the command line, doesn’t mean it’s right for everyone, and should be elevated and presented as the primary interface.

3 Likes

Yes, new users struggle with the obvious stuff, I get how you wouldn’t want to present this too obviously on the basic controls, it would confuse.

1 Like