Missing total numbers in admin stats view

AI-generated summary

In the admin stats view, wolftune reports that the total numbers for “Signups” and “New Contributors” are missing, even when the value is zero — unlike other metrics that display totals. Johani explains this is intentional: changes between -2 and +2 are considered statistically insignificant, so the trend indicator (up/down arrow) is hidden, though the chart remains. wolftune counters that the plain sum should still be shown regardless of trend, since users shouldn’t need to calculate totals manually — the sum isn’t the trend itself. maiki suggests clicking the chart title to access a detailed report with exact figures. wolftune acknowledges this workaround but still advocates for displaying the sum directly in the overview, proposing the hiding logic be limited to only the trend indicator (arrow), not the total number — calling it a minor but sensible UX improvement.

See this screenshot of a weekly stats:

Signups and New Contributors have no numbers for the total where the other items have that. Even if the total is 0, it should be shown.

This is a bit of an edge case. We consider changes between -2 and +2 to be insignificant. If the change for the period is in that range, you’ll still get the chart but not the trend indicator.

7 likes

What about showing the plain number without the trend indicator?

The bit you quoted could have a situation where the number is higher, like 79 or whatever and yet it’s still not showing any number. Surely someone wouldn’t bother adding up all the numbers in the chart. The plain sum is not itself the trend.

If you click on the title of each trend chart, it takes you to a report with the cold, hard numbers. :slight_smile:

Thanks. It still seems trivial and sensible to still show the sum. Just would need to make the hiding command affect only the up/down trend part of the view. Minor quibble I’ll admit.