In a [Hiring] thread titled “Build an iOS App” under the Marketplace category, nexo seeks an experienced Discourse developer to build an iOS app based on the guide: Whitelisted Discourse app with Push Notifications via OneSignal. The project must be completed in one week, with a budget of $500 — payable only if the app is approved and published on the App Store. sau226 expresses interest and invites PMs to discuss. pfaffman raises concerns about Apple’s policy against publishing apps that are essentially websites. nexo counters that some Discourse-based web apps (like SWAPD and TekInvestor) have been approved, suggesting added features — such as a login screen — may help meet Apple’s criteria. davidkingham confirms this, sharing that Penar used a login screen to differentiate the app, but notes his own app (using Memberful SSO) was rejected despite push notifications via OneSignal. Stephen adds that push notifications may serve as a differentiator, though davidkingham confirms they weren’t sufficient in his case. Ultimately, nexo announces sau226 successfully completed the project with “thorough, professional, and superb work,” and hints at future platform expansion. Damian_Boon asks if sau226 is available for another project, to which sau226 replies they’re currently unavailable but open to future discussions via PM.
They’re pretty inconsistent with this rule, since there are some web apps on the App Store. I know for sure two Discourse websites (SWAPD and TekInvestor) - Penar published those apps. I believe there needs to be a sort of feature implemented that adds more value to be considered an app..that I don’t know how Penar implemented
Penar did this by adding a login screen which made the experience slightly different and ‘easier’ than using the website. I got caught by this because I use Memberful as an SSO so we couldn’t use the login screen and they rejected it.
It just occurred to me that I could add some silly little feature related to my site (photography in my case) that would get around this.
In my case it wasn’t enough of a differentiator even though I was using onesignal for push notifications, that was my argument and they still rejected it.
I’m probably not going to be able to make another app in the near future. That said, if you want to PM me the details, I can come back to you when I take this off the backburner.