In a discussion titled “Show top topics and latest topics?” under the Feature category, nityeshaga proposes a homepage design that balances visibility between top-performing and newly created topics, arguing that current options (Featured, Latest, Top) fail to reflect true community engagement or surface new content effectively. They suggest an eligibility metric combining “popularity” (views, likes, replies) and “freshness” (recency) to prioritize topics that serve both readers and new contributors. Stephen suggests this could be implemented as a plugin. codinghorror disagrees, calling the combination redundant. nityeshaga clarifies their intent, emphasizing that the goal is to avoid burying new topics while still highlighting popular ones — serving both audiences without redundancy, as the two signals (popularity and freshness) are complementary, not overlapping. The core request is for a dynamic, algorithmically weighted homepage that reflects both community interest and content recency.
I would like to have a homepage design that prioritises top topics in my Community and new topics.
The options that I have right now don’t really suite this need:
Categories with Featured - along with requiring a lot of manual work it shows an equal number of topics per category and hides the true distribution of conversation
Categories with Latest - this prioritises topics that have had the latest conversation in them; doesn’t really serve any of the above purposes
Categories with Top - this doesn’t show the latest topics
Is there some way I can achieve my desired goal already?
Maybe I didn’t give a very clear explanation but I would disagree with the conclusion that what I asked for is going to produce any redundancy.
So, here’s my 2nd shot at providing a better explanation:
I would like my Community to have a homepage that shows the top conversations (topics) in the Community but gives extra weights to new topics so that they don’t get lost.
So, if there was such a homepage design in which an eligibility_metric determined what stayed on it, this eligibility_metric would be a weighted sum (or product or some other mathematical function idk) of:
popularity - determined by the number of views, likes, comments, etc.
freshness - determined by how new the topic
I would like such a homepage in my Community because it will keep in mind the interests of both:
the members who come to read/engage with other people’s posts and
the members who come to share by creating a new topic