The discussion revolves around the ‘Nice Share’ badge on Discourse, where user seanblue noticed the badge was awarded for posts without links or even posts not authored by them. sam clarified that the badge is based on incoming links, not outgoing ones, and depends on unique IP addresses clicking a link with the user’s username in it. codinghorror further explained that sharing a link with u=username in the URL credits the user for the share. seanblue realized they had shared the post in the same topic, which explained the lack of visible connection or click indicators, resolving the confusion.
On community.wanikani.com I’ve gotten the Nice Share badge three times in the last few weeks. However when I checked the posts associated with each badge, two of the posts don’t contain any links and one of the posts isn’t even mine!
I went and checked even earlier badges, and many of them are also for posts without links or posts owned by other users.
These posts are not the kind I would have shared links to, backed up by the fact that there’s no indicator below the posts saying I linked to them. That is, none of these:
See how it says u=codinghorror on the end? That’s the important part for the purposes of this discussion.
Anyone clicking on that gives my account “credit” for the share. If enough unique IP addresses visit the page from that URL, I will get the share badge because enough people (could be you who shared the link, could be me.. could be anyone) clicked on that particular link with my username in it.
I looked a little more, and I actually did share the most recent Nice Share post… in the same topic. Since it was shared in the same topic there was no indication of the posts being connected, and because of the preview there was no bubble showing how many times it was clicked. But either way, I think that solves the mystery. Thanks!