Badge Progress Trackers

AI-generated summary

The discussion centers on implementing a badge progress tracker to help users monitor their advancement toward earning badges, particularly those requiring sustained activity like consecutive daily visits. Kohl_Kenerly proposes a visual tracker that resets for repeatable badges and displays earned counts. The idea is well-received by sunjam, JimPas, and TheTechRobo, who appreciate the motivational and transparent nature of such a feature. Kohl_Kenerly adds that they personally enjoy tracking progress, echoing the sentiment of others. However, tobiaseigen raises a concern: publicly displaying progress may foster unhealthy gamification, shifting focus from genuine contribution to badge chasing. They reference a YouTube video to support the argument that intrinsic motivation — showing up and contributing meaningfully — should naturally lead to recognition, rather than being driven by visible metrics. The debate reflects a tension between user engagement and maintaining community values centered on authentic participation.

I think a very useful feature would be the ability to track your progress on earning badges.

For example, on a certain forum that I am on, there is a badge that requires you to visit the forums for 100 consecutive days. It is very difficult to keep track of this after some time goes by.

I feel like this would be a pretty good solution to that problem:

14 likes

Then, on badges you can earn more than once the tracker would reset, and the number of times you already have this badge goes into the top left corner next to the check mark:

6 likes

I love this idea. It would incorporate nicely with our desire for badges to reflect people’s contributions to our Nonprofit.

7 likes

It does seem like a good idea. I like this. I have a couple of users who are really into tracking their visits and badge progress.

5 likes

We are in the same situation. It’s something I even personally enjoy.

3 likes

This definitely seems a good idea – I’d love to see how close I am to getting that specific badge – I want it so much! :slight_smile:

3 likes

I believe this idea has come up before. The problem is precisely this:

Showing this information to users creates incentives that arguably are unhealthy. People in the community should just focus on showing up regularly, being valuable contributors and members, and the kudos and recognition follow naturally from that.

9 likes