More default badges for users who flag often

AI-generated summary

The discussion centers on introducing default badges for users who frequently submit accepted flags, to recognize their role in maintaining community standards and reducing spam. Pad_Pors proposes tiered badges (e.g., for 10, 25 accepted flags), arguing that such recognition encourages constructive participation. maiki questions the utility in communities where flagging is rare, while codinghorror suggests badges might encourage more flagging overall. maiki cautions that flagging is often reactive and risks incentivizing users to “look” for things to flag, potentially increasing false reports. papyrophilia echoes this concern, warning that highlighting flagging specifically could raise mod workload and false flagging, and suggests broader badges like “Civility” instead. riking proposes concrete thresholds (10/100 helpful flags) and themed badges like “Spam Fighter.” codinghorror notes the stigma of being seen as “a rat.” Pad_Pors counters that badges should reward only accepted flags and that reframing flags as “criticizing” or “reviewing” (via custom icons/messages) fosters constructive contributions—even flagging good topics with poor titles helps admins. papyrophilia agrees on accepting only verified flags but notes mods may still face increased volume of both false and legitimate flags to review. The conversation balances incentivizing moderation support against unintended consequences like gaming the system or increased moderation burden.

I know that badges can be added using some queries , but I feel it’d be good if there are some badges by defualt for users who have accepted flag often, as they help admins keep everything well-organized and spam-free.

e.g. those who have 10 accepted flag, those who have 25 accepted flag, … .

2 Likes

No one flags anything in my communities, so these badges would not be useful to me. That’s my personal “first check” for a default. :thinking:

2 Likes

Right but his underlying idea is correct – if we encourage more flagging maybe it will happen more? :thinking:

4 Likes

I see it as a balance between: discovery of a useful feature, and encouraging others to flag.

I consider flagging to be a negative action most times (meaning it’s a reaction to something adverse, rather than a proactive step on the badge-reciever’s part), but I’m open to thoughts around that. I just don’t want folks “looking” to flag, ya know? But again, not a problem I’m solving. :slight_smile:

I think you are both right is what I am saying :wink:

2 Likes

@Pad_Pors, I see what you’re thinking–you’d like users to take more personal responsibility for community standards and more personal reflection on their own behavior, where the badge is a visual reminder. :+1:

My thought is that singling out the specific helpful community behavior of “flagging” might increase the frequency of false flagging, as well as mod workload.

:thinking: I know there are a ton of badges, but I’m not familiar with all of them or how they can be customized. Are there any that more vaguely speak to keeping the community on track? Maybe a “Civility” badge (as in the auto-message, “Thanks for keeping our community civil”)?

10 and 100 “helpful” / “agreed” flags would be a good starting point for more badges. If you want to get more specific, we could do things like 10 agreed spam: “Spam Fighter”

3 Likes

Flagging is a difficult scenario. Nobody wants to feel like “a rat”. :rat:

1 Like

that’s why it’s better if only accepted flags are being awarded, and not all the flags.

not a rat, but a criticizer or even a reviewer. we have changed the name, the icon, and the auto-messages of flags in our community toward the criticize meaning, and it works quite well. from that point people want to have a contribution toward making the conversations better.

afterward, users even flag good topics but with bad (unclear) subjects, and this helps our admins find those topics which need moderation in topic title much faster.

1 Like

I agree about awarding the badges based only on accepted flags, but mods might still have to wade through increased false (and legitimate) flags, to determine which flags are accepted in the first place. :face_with_monocle:

1 Like