New Forum Idea, is Discourse a good fit?

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

The discussion revolves around whether Discourse is suitable for a new forum focused on bike reviews organized by manufacturer and model. Reserves explains that the forum’s structure relies heavily on categories, with each bike model having its own dedicated section, aiming to reduce noise and improve user experience by focusing on specific models. They question if Discourse, which encourages a more flat, discussion-based structure, is the right fit compared to traditional forums that are more category-driven. Canapin asks for clarification, and Reserves clarifies that traditional forums often use deeper category hierarchies, while Discourse limits this to two levels and promotes tags instead. Canapin notes that deep category structures are rare and often reorganizable. rizka suggests looking at the Car Talk Community as an example of effective tag-based organization. HAWK adds that Discourse can be customized, such as setting the categories page as the homepage, allowing for a more structured, category-focused experience.

Hi,

I’m researching setting up a new Forum Community.

The aim of the forum is to have users find & add bikes reviews by Manufacturer & Model.

Every model of bike will have its own specific Category, this is the key to the offering.

For example:

Manufacturer 1

  • Bike Model 1
  • Bike Model 2

Canyon Bikes

  • Ultimate CF SL Disc 8.0
  • Roadlite CF 8.0

The Forum isn’t actually about Bikes, but easiest way to explain it. Here is what I know about the potential users.

  • Users will probably be interested in & comparing 1 to 3 bikes, if they are interested in the Roadlite CF 8.0 for example they will have very specific questions about it and be interested in reviews on that model.

  • There are 100’s of reviews about specific bikes in many places on the web, users / content creators would link to these reviews in the specific bike model section, so users can come to one place to read about that bike model specifically.

  • The forum should ask for and display the following for each user so each review has context for other users

  • Height

  • Weight

  • Experience

So what I’m hopefully getting across is that Categories are key to this forum; there are many forums for general bike discussions & users discussing different models, but it’s very noisy and disparate.

Questions!

Does it feel like Discourse be a good fit here? I’m drawn to it because it’s modern, lightweight and feels different to a more traditional forum.

However the way my Forum is to be structured being quite tight may possibly fit a more traditional Forum?

Out of the box it seems that Discourse encourages discussions based on latest topics / discussions in more of a flat structure.

Where as I feel my users will only have interest in a few topics. However interesting the chat maybe about Bike X & Y, they will have zero interest in it as Bike X & Y are not suitable for them.

Would appreciate thoughts as in early stages of research.

Thanks!

2 לייקים

What do you mean by that?

When you say about “may possibly fit a more traditional Forum”, what kind of feature typical from a “more traditional forum” do you think about? :thinking:

3 לייקים

I feel like more traditional forums are Category based, where Discourse encourages a more flat structure.

Could be wrong but that’s how I see it for now.

לייק 1

Do you know a lot of forums that use more than 2 categories levels and where it couldn’t be properly reorganized?

But you’re right, here you can “only” have categories → subcategories. Using tags is encouraged as an alternative to more category depth.

2 לייקים

Check out the Car Talk Community. They’ve nailed what you are trying to achieve - using tags.

9 לייקים

That’s a personal choice. You can have your Categories page as the default homepage rather than Latest if you so choose.

4 לייקים