How safe is a closed category?

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

The discussion revolves around the security of a closed category in Discourse, specifically whether sensitive topics within it can be accessed only by authorized group X. albtuz asks if there’s any way outsiders could breach the category. Thomas_G reassures that only members of group X can access it. However, Stephen clarifies that administrators can always view everything. EricGT adds a technical layer: since posts are stored in PostgreSQL, anyone with OS-level access to the database files, a database dump, or unencrypted backup files could potentially access the data — unless protections like encryption are in place. Stephen notes that for CDCK customers (like albtuz), such low-level access is typically not available, reducing those risks. In short: while category-level permissions are robust and prevent regular users from accessing restricted content, admins retain full visibility, and physical/database-level access remains a theoretical risk — though often mitigated in managed environments like CDCK.

Say that I have a category A where only a certain group X has Create / Reply / See access.

This might sound stupid but I must ask, sorry for my ignorance.

Can sensitive topics be held within A by X members with 100% certainty that no users out of X may have access in any way to those topics?

Have you experienced any way to hack through a category security?

There is no way someone else, except from group A, to see the closed category.

Or an administrator.

They can always see everything.

Post are stored in the database and Discourse is using PostgreSQL as the software that runs the database.

So the following statements relate to access that starts from there.

Since the database is a set of files anyone who has OS level access, e.g. bash prompt, and access to the files making up the database has access.

Anyone who has a dump of the database has access.

Anyone who has access to the backup files. The backup files might have additional builtin protections that limit the access, but one needs to check that, e.g the backup system encrypts the files during backup.

As @albtuz appears to be a CDCK customer, much of that access isn’t available.