Why the hamburger-menu became so blackish?!

AI-generated summary

The discussion centers on the recent change to the hamburger menu’s color scheme, which has shifted to black from a previous bluish style. Pad_Pors questions whether this change was intentional and suggests it should have been introduced via a new theme (e.g., “all-black”) rather than altering defaults. ondrej confirms the change is intentional, citing improved readability. EricGT notes that with the discourse-theme-switcher plugin and Dark mode selected, the black menu becomes hard to read, though switching to Light mode resolves the issue. j.jaffeux explains the problem stems from the plugin hardcoding colors instead of using Discourse’s theme variables like $primary or $secondary. In post 5, j.jaffeux reiterates the change is intentional, noting maintaining hundreds of themes for every variation isn’t feasible, and that the new design improves readability and consistency — though users can restore the old look if desired. EricGT clarifies no offense was intended and appreciates the insight into theme variables, mentioning they’re evaluating whether to keep the theme-switcher or switch to Hamburger Theme Selector. j.jaffeux reassures no offense was taken and suggests relying on light/dark modes may be less risky. The thread reflects a UX trade-off between consistency, readability, and theme flexibility.

all the links in the hamburger menu became black, wasn’t the previous bluish style better?

if this is intentional, isn’t it better if it appears in a new theme, e.g. all-black, rather than changing the previous defaults?

1 like

Yes this is intentional. It is clearer to read now that before.

2 likes

Not so easy to read when using discourse-theme-switcher with Dark selected

image

Luckily switching to Light is easy which makes the menu readable with a user default theme of Light

image

3 likes

That’s because this component is hardcoding some values it shouldn’t be hardcoding and rely on the various colors we have: $primary, $secondary, …

5 likes

Yes this is intentional. If we had to do this for everything we would end up with hundreds of themes to maintain and that would be impossible. I’m sorry this change is annoying you, but it doesn’t prevent usage of the forum, is arguably more readable and homogenise a bunch of things. Last but not least, it’s easy to bring back previous behavior if you want to.

2 likes

I hope I didn’t offend anyone with the earlier post. No intent to do so.

Thanks for noting $primary, $secondary. As a programmer I understand the importance of such but as one who has not created a theme yet, still don’t know the details but will keep this in mind.

I installed discourse-theme-switcher yesterday on our site and while I like it and some of our users like it I am not convinced to leave it installed and currently seeking facts on deciding whether to uninstall it and try Hamburger Theme Selector. Your post has given me a valuable fact. Thanks. :grinning:

2 likes

Not offended, just exposing the facts :stuck_out_tongue: I don’t know much this component, but yes I think relying on light/dark seems less risky.

4 likes

This topic was automatically closed after 5 days. New replies are no longer allowed.