In a discussion about wiki post permissions in Discourse, chaddyer questions the default settings, which restrict who can make a post a wiki (TL3) while allowing broader editing access. They suggest flipping the defaults to align with their intuition. Stephen explains the rationale: limiting who can initiate a wiki (TL3) ensures only trusted users create them, while allowing wider editing encourages community refinement — keeping wikis focused and high-quality. He warns that reversing this could lead to too many wikis edited by too few, undermining the collaborative spirit. maiki frames it as two separate permissions: who can make a post a wiki, and who can edit it. They note that “self-wiki” is rarely needed and recommend setting wiki status at the category level. They caution that allowing low-trust users to turn posts into wikis — especially in non-wiki categories — could disrupt stable conversations, though lowering the edit threshold (e.g., to TL1) is fine if broader collaboration is desired. Overall, the default settings aim to balance control and collaboration, but can be adjusted based on community needs and moderation strategy.
Contemplating wiki posts and permissions. The default is the inverse of what I would have thought so I fear I’m missing something re the dynamics of wiki type posts.
Trust Level 3 is going to represent a fraction of your total user base unless you’re doing something to artificially increase its membership.
The rationale is that only select users should be able to make their post a wiki, but any normal user can contribute. That way you’re going to hopefully going to end up with a small number of wiki topics, refined by the widest audience.
Swapping that logic allows for a much larger number of topics, edited by a minority. I don’t know your user base so can’t comment on specifics, but that’s really the opposite of wikis in general, isn’t it?
“self wiki” never comes up for me, I generally set posts to be wiki by default at the category level.
Sometimes you don’t want a wiki, you want a message that will become stable as the edit grace period, because that’s important for consistent conversation (the main thing Discourse is going for). Having lower trust levels turn any conversation into a wiki, even in categories where it doesn’t make sense could cause confusion… but you are probably okay with having it lower.
You definitely want min trust to edit wiki post to be low if you want more people to edit them. TL1 is fine for that.