I’m facing the exact same issue. The user is almost eligible for TL3 (as per the requirements report that is missing for TL2), but hasn’t been auto-promoted for TL2 yet.
@Aylin have you found the culprit on your instance?
My scenario is similar to yours, his trust level isn’t locked and visually comparing the stats all requirements (which are the defaults) are met.
In my instance, though, all users are created via SSO and I’m using this user as a reference for my analysis - because I’m sure he should be auto-promoted -, but my community has only 2 TL2 users while 996 users are TL1, which I find a very odd proportion.