Configurable/new default for "Votes" sorting

AI-generated summary

In a discussion about improving the “Votes” sorting feature for topics, maiki proposes excluding closed topics from the default “Votes” view (/latest?order=votes) to improve relevance, especially for categories using topic voting. The suggestion stems from feedback in another thread where closed topics were appearing at the top, reducing usefulness. Falco suggests an alternative: creating a new “Approved Proposals” category to move topics to after they’ve received enough votes — implying the plugin may have been designed for customer feedback workflows. Headless supports the idea but recommends making the inclusion or exclusion of closed topics configurable, allowing flexibility for different use cases. maiki acknowledges the “Approved Proposals” idea but notes it doesn’t fit their workflow (used for group activity boards), though they’re open to considering moving topics out. The core proposal remains: should the default “Votes” sort exclude closed topics, or should this be a configurable option? The community is invited to weigh in.

Continuing the discussion from Delete Topics within a date in a specific category:

I didn’t want to sidestep the date-range-operation on topics, so here’s a different proposal we make it so the “Votes” (/latest?order=votes) view for a category not show closed topics.

I don’t know what folks expect, and therefore whether it should just be a different default (sans closed/solved topics) or configurable. Please discuss. :slight_smile:

Create a new category for “Approved Proposals” and close & move topics there after they had enough votes to pass?

1 Like

I think your change helps immensely. I do think it should be configurable though. Maybe an option to include/exclude closed topics from the sort. This would easily add a new feature to the plug-in as well as keep how it was previously in use cases someone wants closed topics to show up.

That’s interesting. I use votes for a group activity board, so having a secondary category and a manual task isn’t part of our workflow; based on “Approved Proposals” I’m guessing the plugin was made for customer-service/product feedback.

I’ll consider moving them out…