I have been very excited to try out discourse. I have setup an instance on Digital Ocean but I haven’t been able to go past the email verification step in past few hours. I am wondering why would you guys put something such as SMTP upfront to just setup and try your platform? Why couldn’t it be like Wordpress where you can setup email system later?
AI-generated summary
In a discussion titled “Why is email verification required upfront?”, user hyd504 expresses frustration over being blocked by email verification during Discourse setup, comparing it unfavorably to WordPress’s more flexible email configuration. JimPas explains that email verification is essential to establish the first Administrator — ensuring only authorized users can configure the site — and suggests searching Meta for SMTP setup help. IAmGav emphasizes that Discourse and WordPress are fundamentally different platforms and offers direct assistance with SMTP. merefield suggests creating an admin account via the Rails console as an alternative. Finally, codinghorror underscores that email is a core identity mechanism in Discourse — foundational since its inception — and notes that while command-line bypasses may work for testing, a functional site for public use absolutely requires reliable email delivery. The consensus is that email verification isn’t a barrier but a design necessity for security, identity, and usability in Discourse.
You have to have someone in charge - an Administrator - to set up and customise Discourse the way you want to. Such setup and customization can only be performed by an Admin. By using email as a way to verify you as the administrator, you will also be automatically logged in and set as an Admin as soon as you’ve clicked on the verification link.
If you’re having a problem setting up SMTP for sending invites or notifications, just use the search here on Meta. Some people had problems setting theirs up and there are solutions to different mail providers.
This is discourse, totally different concept than WordPress. You can’t compare the two.
If you need help with discourse SMTP, then either use the search function on meta or send me a DM and I’ll help.
Hmmm, have you tried setting up the admin from the rails console?:
In Discourse, email is your identity, this is a fundamental, bedrock part of the design from the earliest days of the project.
For testing purposes you might be able to bypass at the command line, but you’ll never have a working Discourse site (that is to say, usable by anyone other than yourself) without reliably functioning email delivery. ![]()