I joined the community 2 years ago. Since then, I have changed my bio many times. Some days ago, I emptied it. Now, I edited it again and the autobiographer badge has been granted again. I am more than 100% sure I have earned this badge again. Is this normal? I mean, once you join, I think discobot guides you to edit your profile and apparently, the aforementioned badge gets granted. Shouldn’t it be granted only the first time though?
סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית
The discussion revolves around the behavior of the ‘Autobiographer’ badge, which is granted when a user fills out their bio and profile picture. Thomas_G noticed the badge was re-granted after editing his bio again, even though he had previously earned it — and later emptied his bio. simon clarified that the badge is revoked daily if the bio falls below 10 characters, and re-granted when it’s filled again — expected behavior. Thomas_G questioned whether this makes sense, especially since the badge description says “Join us,” implying it’s for new users. simon noted it’s an edge case and framed it as an invitation to join others who’ve filled out their bios. maiki teased that the user’s real concern may be that badges should be permanent, not revocable. gerhard defended the current system, arguing the badge rewards current profile completeness, not past actions — to prevent gaming. maiki jokingly proposed a complex alternative system with “Autobiotakebacker” and “Thoughtful Autobiographer” badges, predicting chaos. The consensus leans toward this not being a bug, but a feature designed to encourage ongoing profile engagement.
The revocation query for the Autobiographer badge is run daily, so this is the expected behaviour. If you empty your bio (or edit it so that it contains less than 10 characters) you will lose the badge when the daily revocation query is run. If you then add a new bio, you will be granted the badge again.
That’s the confirmation I wanted. Does it make sense though? In the end of the badge description, is says “Join us”. If I am a regular though, I have joined and engaged with the community months before.
It’s a bit of an edge case. I just realized that I’ve never filled out my bio on Meta. For my case, I’d read the badge description as inviting me to join the other users who have filled in their bio.
In your case, the badge should well be earned, as it is the first time you filling out the bio. Why should you earn this again though if you empty it and forget it for a day, then editing it again?
It doesn’t not make sense.
If sounds like your crux is badges should be permanent, not revocable, is that correct? ![]()
That’s what I expected & that’s why I posted in Contribute > Bug ![]()
I don’t think this is a bug. You get that badge for having a bio and profile picture, not for writing and deleting a bio. We wouldn’t want you to game the system, would we. ![]()
This badge is granted for filling out your user profile and selecting a profile picture. Letting the community know a bit more about who you are and what you’re interested in makes for a better, more connected community.
When you remove those things, you lose the badge and it will be granted again as soon as the requirements are fulfilled.
Instead of granting and revoking, it should work:
- Writing a bio grants Autobiographer
- Removing it revokes Autobiographer, grants repeatable badge: Autobiotakebacker
- If someone has Autobiotakebacker N times, grant: Thoughtful Autobiographer
- Watch the support messages roll in (and crash NaNoWriMo’s forums!)
![]()