The discussion revolves around the idea of pinning the first post of a topic to the top, especially in long threads where the original content (like a poll) may be overlooked. nildarar suggests this feature would improve user experience, as users often miss initial information after many replies. ondrej counters that users should start from the first post, but nildarar acknowledges this while emphasizing user expectations shaped by other platforms. Stephen notes that new users start at the OP and that read positions are tracked, making the issue less relevant. codinghorror points out that the first post is already effectively ‘pinned’ and that users can easily jump to the top. nildarar reiterates that despite the existing solution, many users still request this feature, suggesting a UX gap. codinghorror concludes by emphasizing the natural role of the first post as the default ‘pinned’ content.
Yes, you are right.
But, this is what we expect from the user as a designer. Usually, the needs of users are different, and consider these needs makes programs more user-friendly.
All users default read position in a topic which is new to them is the OP.
Unless you’re suggesting that users will regularly edit polls into post 1 once the topic has gotten tens of replies this is a non-issue.
Remember, you will only open a topic further down if you have previously read it, or if linked directly to a reply. Discourse tracks the read position separately for every registered user.
If this is important, then edit the poll into the first post, and link to the first post in downstream replies.
The first post will always be “pinned” to the top of the topic
And there are lots of ways to jump to the top of a topic even if you have a read position in the topic, either from the topic list (try clicking / tapping the post count), or within the topic itself (try clicking / tapping the topic title).
I’ve been reading every post on this site for about eight years now, and “let me pin a random post inside a topic” does not come up very much. Instead, apply your focus to the natural pinned post which already exists in every topic – the first post at the top.