The discussion revolves around a new optional feature in Discourse called the “filtered replies view,” which allows users to focus on specific reply threads. pmusaraj introduced the feature, which can be enabled via the enable filtered replies view site setting. When activated, clicking the “n Replies” button collapses unrelated posts, and the “in-reply-to” button filters posts to highlight a specific reply flow. The feature also includes a sticky bar at the bottom of the page when filtering is active and supports four types of filters: replies, in-reply-to, user-specific posts, and topic summaries. seanblue expressed a preference for the older approach, noting that the new workflow slows down quick glances at replies. codinghorror explained that the feature offers a more “threaded” view, similar to Reddit’s behavior, and leverages existing functionality like user-based filtering. seanblue acknowledged that while the feature achieves its goals, he personally wouldn’t want it enabled on Discourse instances he uses regularly.
We have been testing a new flow for filtering replies here on meta.
This has been in core for a few weeks now, and it can be enabled on any up-to-date Discourse site using the enable filtered replies view site setting. When enabled, clicking the “n Replies” button will collapse all posts that are outside that conversation:
The in-reply-to button also does a similar filtering out of posts to help the reader focus on a specific reply flow.
In the videos above, you can also see a sticky bar at the bottom of the page when a filtered conversation is being shown. (There are four kinds of filters, the two mentioned above, replies and in-reply-tos, plus posts by a specific user and topic summaries.)
Feel free to use the replies below to share feedback on this feature.
Personally, I prefer the old approach. Generally, when I click the n Replies button, it’s to get a quick glance at the replies and then I keep scrolling through the topic. The new workflow makes that take much longer.
Right, this is an alternative for people that want a more “threaded” view of the world on their Discourse. It also leverages existing functionality when you filter a topic by user, that is:
enter a long topic
click or tap avatar of a user who posted a few times
It reminds me a bit of how Reddit works, where drilling into a top-level reply opens that reply and all its sub-replies in a new view. Just more streamlined I guess. In that sense I think the features achieves what it sets out to achieve. I just personally wouldn’t want it enabled on Discourse instances I use regularly.