Undescriptive Twitter topic titles

AI-generated summary

The community is discussing undescriptive Twitter topic titles. Terrapop pointed out that pasting a Twitter link into the title composer field pulls the username as the title, resulting in uninformative titles. They suggested either leaving the title field blank or using the tweet text as the title.

neil created a PR to address this issue, which was merged into the latest beta. Now, Twitter links will leave the title field blank, prompting users to enter their own title. Terrapop and neil confirmed the resolution.

We have a community where people post a lot of Tweets. When you paste a link to a Twitter post into the title composer field it pulls the username for the topic title.

This creates a lot of topics with undescriptive titles. I think this behavior should be changed for Twitter.

I would rather have no title (so that the user is forced to add one) instead of always have the undescriptive usernames grabbed as titles in this case.

So you are specifically referring to the behavior where the URL is pasted into the title field in the new topic composer?

Yes, exactly. It’s good for almost all other sources, but for Twitter, it always pulls the username as the title for the topic. I would prefer either no title for Twitter (so users have to add one as Tweets do not have a proper title) or use the Tweet text and truncate (if too long) instead.

I’ve made a PR to handle this case. Twitter links will leave the title field blank so users will need to enter their own title.

https://github.com/discourse/discourse/pull/12332

Thank you @neil, very much appreciated.

It’s merged into the latest beta.