שקיפות רבה יותר לגבי חומרת בעיות אבטחה

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

In a discussion titled ‘Greater transparency over severity of security issues,’ core expressed concern that Discourse’s security updates lack sufficient detail, noting that recent release notes only mention a vague security fix and do not link to the corresponding HackerOne report or disclose its severity. core suggested including such links and severity ratings for greater transparency. In response, jomaxro explained that security details are intentionally kept minimal to prevent malicious actors from exploiting vulnerabilities before sites can upgrade. They clarified that while the commit message serves as the official record of the fix, users can review security-related commits directly via the [Discourse GitHub repository](https://github.com/discourse/discourse/search?o=desc&q=SECURITY&s=committe r-date&type=Commits). Regarding HackerOne reports, jomaxro noted that public disclosure was previously allowed but discontinued due to abuse, and such reports are no longer made public. The team prioritizes responsible disclosure to protect users while still acknowledging security fixes in release notes.

I believe the discourse team could do a better job at transparency over security issues. The last one only says:

This beta includes 1 security fix for issues reported by our community and HackerOne 8.

  • Prefer Loofah for processing cooked HTML

And I was not able to find said report on HackerOne.

Ideally the release would include a link to the HackerOne report and the severity of the security issue at hand.

Hey @core,

The security fix info is intentionally non-detailed. Sites upgrade at different speeds, while we want to share that there was a security fix, we don’t want to provide detail to allow malicious actors to easily exploit it. The security fix is the commit message, so you can always look at our GitHub repo for security commits to see the code changes if you like.

We do not make our HackerOne reports public. While we previously allowed hackers to request disclosure of their reports, due to abuse received after doing so on multiple occasions we discontinued that.