In a support thread titled “How can I set up notifications as I like?”, lipman seeks clarification on customizing notification settings. They want browser and mobile app notifications for every new post, but email notifications only for direct mentions or replies to their own posts—not just threads they’ve participated in. They also note that browser notifications (on Windows 10/Chrome) only appear while the forum is open and vanish quickly from the Action Center, questioning if this is intended behavior. In a follow-up, lipman asks for confirmation if their desired setup is impossible. codinghorror initially expresses confusion, but after lipman clarifies, codinghorror explains that emails are only sent when no browser has recently pinged the site—meaning notifications are only escalated to email if the user is not actively visiting the forum. This implies that email and browser notifications are not independently configurable per category or trigger type, but rather email is a fallback for inactivity. The thread highlights a gap between user expectations for granular notification control and the current system’s behavior.
The notification setup isn’t clear to me. Or maybe what I have in mind is simply not possible:
I’d like to get browser (and mobile app) notifications for every single post, but not e-mails. I do want e-mails for certain things such as when somebody mentions me or replies directly to a post of mine (not just to a thread I had posted something in).
Is that possible?
Also, browser notifications (Win 10, Chrome, desktop) only seem to work while I have the forum open in a tab, and they disappear after a few seconds from the “action center”, that is not just the pop-up thingy. Is this supposed to be like that?
Sorry that I wasn’t clear.
If I set up notifications, say watching a category, will this invariabley be the same for e-mail notifications and for instant notifications in a browser/device, if activated there? Or can I set them up separately, say browser notifications for all new posts, but e-mails only when somebody quotes me, or one category for browser notifications and another per e-mail?
Emails are only sent when none of your web browsers have pinged the website recently. Notifications are only turned into emails in that specific case – when you are not on the website in any form.