תרשימי Pageview (שוב)

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

BryanV revisits the topic of pageview plots, noting that recent updates have made the annual-range visualization illegible. They suggest switching to weekly aggregation for better readability and insist that bars must have sufficient width to be legible and hoverable. They also criticize the addition of vertical gridlines, calling them visual clutter that hinders quick comparison between bars, and recommend reverting the change or offering a simpler style option (or CSS override guidance). In a follow-up post, BryanV points out that graphs for metrics like signups or new contributors should not display non-integral ticks or floating-point formatting, since these values represent whole people and should be shown as integers for accuracy and clarity.

I know I had previously asked for aggregation on the annual range, but the recent updates render the visualization illegible:

Well-meaning suggestions:

  • A weekly (rather than monthly) aggregation would be comfortable and preferable at this scale
  • Regardless, the bars need to be configured with enough width to be legible and hoverable

Lastly, the recent addition of vertical gridlines is a real negative IMO. It’s just visual clutter that is distracting and makes comparing heights across different bars much more difficult to do at a glance. Having a vertical gridline corresponding to some empty tick in between bars tells the viewer absolutely nothing. [*] I would suggest reverting this change, or offering a configuration for a simpler style (or if this can be overridden via CSS theme, any pointers are appreciated).

[*]: properly this would be a categorical range with discrete weeks or months as the factors, not a datetime range at all.

לייק 1

Also as long as I am commenting on the visualization design, it’s not useful/appropriate have non-integral ticks (or format integers as floating point) in graphs like the signups or new contributors since those will always be whole numbers of people:

לייק 1