A user, mirkomen77, is seeking help with email notifications on their Discourse instance. They want staff to receive emails for new topics and the original poster to receive emails when staff reply, but no emails are being sent despite enabling mailing list mode and disabling emails for non-staff. pfaffman suggests checking the mail logs and considering whether mailing list mode functions as expected. mirkomen77 later resolves the issue by adjusting the email time window mins setting from a high value to 10 minutes, restoring email functionality.
The last time we had emails on we ended up sending thousands of emails every day so we disabled it.
What we are looking for is to send an email to staff every time there is a new topic, and send an email to the OP when a staff member replied to that topic.