Saif initiates a discussion on UX improvements for the end-of-topic area, specifically regarding the coexistence of Suggested Topics and Related Topics. The goal is to streamline the “what should I read next?” experience, proposing options such as merging them into a single list, making Related Topics the default, or removing Suggested Topics entirely.
manuel notes that Suggested Topics are primarily useful for casual visitors rather than regular users. They argue that the current layout adds cognitive load and noise, suggesting that suggested lists should align with the topic width to reduce visual clutter.
EricGT highlights that while general users rarely use Suggested Topics, moderators rely heavily on Related Topics for tasks like tag checking and closing duplicates. He requests that changes do not hinder moderation workflows and suggests a graphical spatial interface using colored dots to visualize topic similarity.
Tris20 distinguishes the two features by user intent: Related Topics function as “Just in Time Search” results for users seeking specific answers, whereas Suggested Topics cater to browsing behavior. They advocate for prioritizing Related Topics at the end of threads to aid users in finding information or recognizing dead ends.
AJ_Quick proposes automatically curating both sets into a single list, arguing that 99% of users will not manually toggle between tabs. satonotdead mentions disabling the selector via CSS, which AJ_Quick agrees is a common approach. Dmitry_Krasnoperov clarifies that users can also set the “Suggested topics” count to zero in settings to remove the feature entirely.
Overall, the community leans toward reducing choice fatigue by merging or hiding one of the lists, with a stronger preference for Related Topics among power users and moderators, while acknowledging the browsing utility of Suggested Topics for new visitors.