משוב על Ask Discourse

[Saif (Saif Murtaza)]

If you find yourself here, welcome to the feedback topic for chatting with Ask Discourse.

In addition to the Ask Discourse site, you can now use chat to message the helpful persona directly. Coming soon

Since we have rolled this out, we would love to hear your thoughts as we improve the experience.

• How was the overall experience?
• What type of questions are you usually asking? Why?
• Are you finding the responses helpful?
• Any problems?
• What would you like to see in the future?

Thank you in advance for your feedback

[Ed_S]

בדרך כלל אני מוצא ש-Ask עוזר למדי. אבל היום הוא סיפק שני קישורים לפוסטים שאני לא יכול לגשת אליהם. אני מניח שהם קוטלגו לקטגוריה עם גישה מוגבלת - חבל, כאן, כי הם נראו כאילו הם עשויים היו להיות שימושיים.

[one1]

I asked it, “when a moderator rejects a flag, does the post get unhidden” and it gave me general information about non-Discourse forums. Shouldn’t all the advice be assumed to be about discourse? What is the point of the tool if it isn’t oriented that way?

https://ask.discourse.com/discourse-ai/ai-bot/shared-ai-conversations/x2JGXv9nCQBdFLkaPCJqBA

When I did tell it I was asking about discourse, it gave me a link to a non-existent post: https://meta.discourse.org/t/what-happens-when-a-post-is-flagged/15826

[Canapin (Coin-coin le Canapin)]

@one1

When I did tell it I was asking about discourse, it gave me a link to a non-existent post

I often use ask-discourse, and this is the things that bother me the most. It often makes up links instead of returning real data.

[one1]

המספר של הקישורים ב-meta הוא סופי. אני לא יודע הרבה על LLMs, אבל נראה שאפשר לבדוק מול רשימה של פוסטים אמיתיים.

[mcwumbly (Dave McClure)]

If you see bad answers like that, please do click the button.

That’ll flag them for us so we can see if there is a way to tune things further in the prompt or improve the docs to better surface better answers.

[Lee_Ars]

מצאתי שזה הרבה יותר יעיל מאשר לחפש תשובות במטא — אני יכול להטיל עליו שאילתה אחת בשפה טבעית (כמו “איך אני גורם לדיסקורס לעשות \[דבר\]?”) ולקבל תשובה המורכבת מחלקים מסוכמים מאותם 3-4 חיפושי מטא שהייתי מוצא בסופו של דבר, אבל בלי שאצטרך להשקיע את הזמן כדי למצוא אותם. אני בהחלט מתכנן להמשיך להשתמש בו כשיש לי שאלות מסוג “איך אני עושה” או “האם אפשר” בנוגע לדיסקורס.

[NateDhaliwal]

אבל גם חיפוש AI כאן ב-Meta יכול לספק תוצאות רלוונטיות למדי.

אני לא באמת יכול למחוק את השיחות שלי. אני יכול לסמן אותן, אבל זה יותר מעצבן. האם יש דרך לאפשר למשתמשים רגילים למחוק הודעות פרטיות משלהם עם הבוט?

[sam (Sam Saffron)]

@NateDhaliwal

Is there a way to let normal users delete their own bot PMs?

Not yet, but I feel like this is a request for general “Discourse AI”, ChatGPT has a much nicer option which we should emulate:

Improve managing history on Ask discourse

The implementation in core is a bit better than the one we have on “ask” @awesomerobot I wonder if there is an easy way to port over to the format /discourse-ai/ai-bot/conversations uses? (it splits stuff in dates) I also think there is merit in allowing users to easily remove conversations from the sidebar, this control on ChatGPT is great that way: [image]

[matthewruzzi]

I have been getting errors when my reply to one AI response is too similar to my reply to a previous one.

[matthewruzzi]

I also am getting errors when flagging AI responses too quickly.

[HAWK]

Those are standard Discourse JIT messages and don’t apply to Ask Discourse. What bot were you interacting with?

[matthewruzzi]

DiscourseHelper on https://ask.discourse.com/

[HAWK]

I was wrong before when I said those messages don’t apply on ask.discourse— they still do because it is powered by Discourse. You are being hit by the normal spam rate limiting.

[awesomerobot (Kris)]

Usually the “too similar” message only happens when the post you’re trying to make is identical to an earlier post… I also notice that you submitted two identical flags, which might have been the cause of the “creating topics too quickly” error… perhaps some messages were attempting to send twice in rapid succession due to a flaky internet connection? this could potentially explain both issues

[one1]

Is there any way to tell the model that queries for the DataExplorer should never end with a ;. I know it seems like a small thing, but when I have to go through several iterations I’m constantly forgetting to remove it.

[twofoursixeight]

The Ask Discourse website feedback involves some links that are useless on this site.

All Questions brings you to /my/messages, which has no use unless messaging a staff member.

The “topics”, “my posts”, “categories”, “my messages”, and “filter” do not serve any use on the site either, as the Ask Discourse site is mainly for Discourse AI chat and not for making topics. Those pages are empty for 99% of people and should redirect back to the AI bot if you are a normal member. Otherwise, the website functions well for asking an AI questions.

The solution is to hide them from the sidebar, only showing the “AI bot” sidebar if possible, and a “back to AI bot” button.

[HAWK]

ask.discourse deliberately defaults to https://ask.discourse.com/discourse-ai/ai-bot/conversations?agent=discourse-helper which hides everything except the conversations. How are you accessing it?

[twofoursixeight]

It’s oddly easy, let me show you through screen recording.
There are a couple ways to access it, as the sidebar isn’t always defaulting to the AI bot one especially in user settings. Clicking all questions, fonts and appearance, or account settings uses a different sidebar than the intended one, that lets you access the unused topics section or unused screens

Note to get back to the ai chat, you click AI bot or the logo.