למה דיסקרוס לא מוסיף בדיקות IP למקטע הלוגים והסינון?

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

wisewords discovered that Discourse’s IP lookup feature doesn’t log actions in the Logs and Screening section, raising concerns about potential abuse. They shared a video demonstrating the feature and mentioned a past incident where IPs were misused for doxxing. RGJ suggested implementing a mechanism similar to email address visibility, with a ‘Show’ button that logs the action. wisewords agreed, while RGJ noted that determined admins could bypass such measures, emphasizing the importance of trust in staff members.

In our forum, we have a few staff members (obviously) that can watch the forum just in case anything bad happens.

While I was messing around with the admin controls, I saw an “IP Check” feature. I used it on myself, and it gave me the exact location.

I saw that this could be abused, so I went to the Logs and Screening section to see if Discourse itself reports if a staff member has checked someone’s IP. It doesn’t.

Here’s a video:

Why does Discourse not report it to the Logs? I believe it should, since this could be abused easily.

(The user in this video was using a VPN for safety purposes.)

3 לייקים

שתכונת “חיפוש IP” עצמה אינה ייחודית ל-Discourse, ניתן פשוט להעתיק/להדביק את כתובת ה-IP ולהשתמש בכלי מיקום IP של צד שלישי.

עם זאת, יהיה טוב שיהיה מנגנון דומה לכתובת הדוא"ל עבור כתובת ה-IP, שבה היא מוסתרת כברירת מחדל ויש לה כפתור “הצג” שמתעד את הפעולה.

העברתי זאת ל-Feature

8 לייקים

I get that, but wouldn’t it be easily abused?

There was this one forum that was a branch to another forum (Gimkit Creative), and the owner of the other forum was secretly farming IPs to later on doxx people using alts on the Gimkit Creative forum.

The user has been long gone, anyway, and it happened last year.

Yeah, that’s what I was thinking about.

לייק 1

Note that an admin can always bypass such a mechanism in various ways (create and download a backup, use the data explorer plugin) so it’s not 100% secure anyway.

If a staff member cannot be trusted, you have a different (and much bigger) problem.

10 לייקים