GIF always shows the first frame when paused

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

In a feature discussion regarding GIF playback, Noble_Fish reported that pausing a GIF displays only the first frame, yet resuming playback continues from the original progress point rather than restarting. This inconsistency was highlighted as a confusing user experience. sam responded that implementing precise frame pausing is technically difficult and would require manual canvas rendering, which could impact performance. Noble_Fish clarified that the core issue is the mismatch between the static first frame shown when paused and the non-reset playback position upon resuming. sam suggested that for consistent behavior, users should consider using MP4 files, which offer perfect pausing capabilities. Noble_Fish acknowledged the technical constraints and confirmed that switching to MP4 is a viable solution for their needs.

Take this casually recorded GIF as an example. When I click the pause button in the bottom right corner, instead of pausing at the moment of clicking, it displays the first frame. However, clicking the button again to resume playback continues with its original progress rather than starting from the beginning—which is quite confusing.

be43d24

I think that if it continues playing with its original progress after clicking, it should display the frame at which it was paused;
Or if it shows the first frame after clicking, then it should reset the entire GIF’s playback progress.

לייק 1

Sorry this is going to have to be a feature request.

Getting this to pause on the exact right frame is extremely hard, there is a compromise to be made. We would have to render stuff by hand using a canvas, which can impact performance.

לייק 1

Eeeeeee… In other words, there is no pause, only play or not play. When not playing, a fixed image is used, and this fixed image is the first frame. So, can I continue to regard it as a bug that when not playing, the first frame is displayed, but playback does not start from frame 1 but from the point where playback stopped?

My main requirement is to eliminate the inconsistency.
(Well, actually, I’ve now exceeded the editable time limit for my topic.)

honestly it is all in the “too hard department”, I think that if you want very consistent behavior you would have to go with mp4 which will give you perfect pause.

4 לייקים

Indeed, I habitually use GIFs on various websites to the extent that I completely forgot about this point. xD
After checking, I found that the performance of MP4 is quite good and sufficient for my needs.

2 לייקים