Upcoming change for the review queue: "Yes" now always means there's a problem

AI-generated summary

awesomerobot announced an upcoming change to the review queue to address user feedback regarding inconsistent button meanings. Previously, the “Yes” button meant “approve” for some items and “reject” for others, causing confusion. The new update, enabled by the Consistent review queue answers upcoming change, standardizes all review questions to ask whether something is wrong. Going forward, “Yes” will always indicate a problem (leading to rejection or action against the content), while “No” will indicate that the item is fine (leading to approval). Additionally, review outcomes will be relabeled as “Problem confirmed” (red) or “No problem found” (green), replacing the previous “Approved” and “Rejected” labels, and filters have been updated to match these new terms. The change can be disabled via Admin > Upcoming changes if necessary. In response, nickdb suggested that the new wording could be improved for better clarity in English.

Based on feedback we’ve made the review queue’s questions point the same way for every kind of item, so you can work the queue without stopping to check what “Yes” means. Going forward “yes” will always mean “yes, there’s a problem with this.”

The update will be enabled as an upcoming change called Consistent review queue answers. If you find the need to disable it, you can do so from Admin > Upcoming changes.

The issue was that some review items asked whether there was a problem (“Is this post spam?”), while others asked for approval (“Approve this topic?”). The same “Yes” button either took action against something or let it through, depending on the item. That’s easy to get wrong when you’re reviewing many items.

What’s changed

  • Every question asks whether something is wrong.
    Queued posts, topics and pending accounts now ask “Is there something wrong with this post / topic / account?”, just like flags do.
  • “Yes” always comes first and always means there’s a problem
    “No” always means it’s fine and lets it through.
  • Reviewed items are labelled by outcome
    Instead of “Flag approved” (green) and “Post rejected” (red), which meant the same thing, every resolved item now shows “Problem confirmed” (red) or “No problem found” (green).
  • Filters have been updated to match
    “Problem confirmed” and “No problem found” replace “Approved” and “Rejected”, and work across every item type.

Let us know if you have any questions or feedback!

23 Likes

I think this wording needs to make a bit more sense in the English language. :slight_smile:

3 Likes