When categories set as home page, sidebar jumps down and "all categories" is highlighted

סיכום מבוסס בינה מלאכותית

tobiaseigen reports a UX issue where setting “categories” as the default home page causes the sidebar to automatically jump to and highlight “All Categories” upon page load or refresh. This behavior obscures the top section of the sidebar, hiding crucial links from new users who are still navigating the interface. The user notes that the issue is inconsistent, sometimes appearing on refresh but not when clicking the logo or Home button, and sometimes persisting after navigation. The suggested fix is to stop the sidebar from auto-scrolling, leaving the scroll position to the user to ensure full visibility of the sidebar’s top links for new members.

I’d like categories to be the default home page view on one of my sites, but when I set it that way the sidebar navigation tends to automatically jump down to “all categories” and highlighting it, obscuring the top part of the menu.

I am able to replicate this here:

  1. set categories to be your home page in your user preferences
  2. refresh the page when at meta.discourse.org
  3. see it jump down

I notice there are some cases when it does not jump down, which makes it even more confusing. For example, go to meta.discourse.org and see it jumps down. Scroll up now and select the logo or HOME and it does not scroll down. Sometimes when I click around on the site and go back home the sidebar remains correct, sometimes it does not.

The desired behavior, I think, is to not move the sidebar automatically in anyway but leave that to the user to do. Not sure though! But when someone logs in for the first time and is still finding their way around I want them to see and become acquainted with the entire sidebar including the top part which has crucial links on it.