Alixx_Joy sought help because their mixed-format category, intended for both events and general topics, was defaulting to creating an “Event” rather than a standard topic. They needed the calendar functionality but wanted the default creation mode to be a topic. NateDhaliwal initially suggested changing the category type from ‘Events’ to ‘Discussion’, noting that users can manually add events later. However, Alixx_Joy reported that even with ‘Discussion’ as the type, the system still defaulted to creating events if the calendar plugin was active.
After several attempts, NateDhaliwal advised configuring the calendar categories setting within the plugin. Alixx_Joy tried removing the category from the settings and re-adding it via the plugin without success. NateDhaliwal eventually identified the correct configuration: keep Discourse post event enabled on, remove ‘Events’ from the category type (so it remains ‘Discussion’), and then explicitly add the category to Events calendar categories. This initially worked for Alixx_Joy.
However, Alixx_Joy later reported the issue reoccurred; despite following the steps, the system eventually reverted to defaulting to event creation. They suggested this behavior warrants an admin UI option to control default creation types more granularly. NateDhaliwal explained that Discourse is a single-page app, so setting changes often require a full page reload to take effect properly, as opposed to just navigating between pages. They recommended that if the issue persists due to UI/UX confusion, Alixx_Joy should open a new topic in the feature request category to propose a dedicated setting for this behavior.
I am creating a mixed format category, which has the ability for events and general topics to enable deadlines to be created as wanted.
The creation in these categories is currently defaulting to creating an event rather than just a topic, is there a way to change this so it creates a topic and we can then decide to create an event instead?
Unfortunately no luck, removed it from category set up, went into the plugin settings and added it via calendar categories and it still defaults to create an event rather than topic
OK, I think I understand what’s going on. You need to disable Discourse post event enabled setting. This removes the event on the topic.
EDIT: A side-effect is that the calendar is gone on the category page. Give me a sec, I’m tweaking a few settings to see what works.
EDIT: @Alixx_Joy Ok here’s how to do it. Remove ‘Events’ as the category type, but leave Discourse post event enabled on. Then, add the category to Events calendar categories.
Just tried again and it had started having the same issues, regardless of removal and reinstatement, closest I got to getting it working was going through one at a time and changing the category, then adding to events calendar categories, but defaulted back to create event automatically after a short while
I think this might be worth escalating as a potential UI option under admin but am unsure how to do so
Changes to settings take effect on reload and not page transitions (because Discourse is a single-page app). If I’m not wrong, the events will be added to topic posts if you add Events to the category types. Perhaps you should open a topic on Feature for this.