Unlimited amount of replies in a private message

AI-generated summary

The discussion revolves around the limitation of private messages in Discourse, with a user, Aussie_Wombat, requesting an “unlimited reply” feature for private messages due to limitations in their community’s private chat. jomaxro explained that private messages were previously unlimited but were capped for performance reasons and suggested creating a group private category as an alternative. mpalmer pointed out that Discourse isn’t designed as a “chat” system and that the cap was put in place to prevent performance problems. Aussie_Wombat thanked everyone for their advice, and pfaffman suggested exploring plugins that provide chat functionality.

Hey there! I was wondering would there be a possibility of adding an “unlimited reply” for private messages?

Because over in the Infinite Flight Community (which runs through discourse) all us Aussies have a private chat and it will keep ending so we have to invite everyone in again - that can get pretty annoying

So just as a little feature it would be great to have this as a feature

-Wombat

Private messages were previously unlimited - they were capped for performance reasons.

You may want to consider asking the Infinite Flight admins to make you a group private category.

6 Likes

Thanks for the reply,

That sounds interesting! I’ll try it.

2 Likes

Yes, the PM post limit is within the control of Discourse, group creation is not.

Edit: and now this reply makes no sense due to your ninja edit. Good luck with the private category request!

2 Likes

Discourse isn’t designed as a “chat” system, so yeah, if you’re using it like that you’ll end up bumping into limitations like the one you’ve found. As @jomaxro said, the cap was put in place because gigantic topics (public or private) cause performance problems, because Discourse wasn’t designed for huge topics, because they’re generally not discussion.

2 Likes

Ok, thanks everyone!

I’ll follow your advices :wink:

1 Like

You might also look at plugins that provide chat functionality.