In a support discussion titled “Pin automatically removed?”, coolstart reports that pinned topics automatically unpin after being read when logged in as admin, but remain pinned for anonymous users. mpalmer explains this is intentional — pinned topics unpin after being read, but anonymous users don’t have read-tracking, so pins remain. Mittineague suggests disabling the behavior via user preferences at https://meta.discourse.org/my/preferences/, specifically unchecking “Automatically unpin topics when I reach the bottom.” coolstart asks if this setting can be applied globally. awesomerobot notes there’s a site-wide setting called automatically unpin topics, and HAWK provides the direct search path: /admin/site_settings/category/all_results?filter=unpin. cpradio clarifies that the site setting only affects new users; to update existing members, a rake task is required to modify their preferences.
Pinned topics get unpinned once they have been read. Anons don’t get read-tracking, because ain’t nobody got the DB space for that. So pinned topics never get marked as “read” by anons.