The discussion revolves around a feature request to allow voting on topics without enabling replies, particularly when a thread needs to be closed to further comments but voting should continue. Chris_S proposes a moderation option to disable replies while keeping voting active, highlighting the issue that reopening closed threads resets vote totals. jayqueue2 suggests a similar feature to create posts that are ‘voting only’ from the start. sam offers a workaround by moving topics to a read-only subcategory, but V1ktor clarifies that this approach prevents voting, indicating the current solution is ineffective. The community seeks a more robust method to maintain voting while restricting replies.
Currently users can vote on a post as well as comment on it. Depending on the topic, sometimes these discussions can get out of control and we need to close the thread. Reopening it zeros out the vote total.
On the other side of that users cannot vote for a closed thread.
I am wondering if is possible or if it would be considered for an option for voting enabled categories to “disable replies” (admin/mod only command)?
This would allow users to post a thread and if the administration determines can disable the thread from further replies but still allow for voting to occur?
Would it also be a helpful or useful feature to be able to create a post that is “voting only” from the start? People cannot reply to it but can only vote on it?
This is actually already doable and @Chris_S I recommend this is what you do.
Create a subcategory under your voting category for “replies closed” allow everyone readonly and then move topics you want to terminate discussion on (but keep voting) there.
Is this still the recommended approach to handle this situation? We tried that, but users are unable to vote if it’s inside read-only sub-category. Would appreciate a clarification.