A more intuitive way to create sub-categories?

AI-generated summary

The discussion revolves around creating a more intuitive way to add sub-categories within a category structure. rishabh suggests that the ‘+ New Subcategory’ button should automatically pre-load the parent category when clicked, improving usability. They propose integrating this feature into the right-side of the category page or using a menu-style foldable option. However, bartv argues the task is too infrequent to justify the effort, while codinghorror notes that such a change might encourage overly complex category structures, which the team aims to avoid. rishabh concludes that the effort may not be worth it, agreeing with the others.

This thought has struck me a few times while creating a site’s category structure. I always create the top-level category, enter it and then my brain looks for the new category button inside this top level category to create sub-categories. Ideally, clicking this + New Subcategory button would pre-load the parent category in our modal:

If we consider implementing this, we’d have to find space in the already crowded right-side of the category page:

image

Maybe we could fold the option in a way similar to the menu on the Categories page?


But before any talk of implementation, I was wondering if anyone else has thought about this? There is a chance that the work required here might not be worth the effort because it is a small change and the current method to create every category from the Categories page is adequate.

7 likes

This is such a low-frequency task that I’m not sure it’s worth it, tbh. From what I remember it wasn’t too hard (but that was 2 years ago).

5 likes

This would also kinda encourage people to create sub-categories in the first place. We would prefer people kept their category structures as simple as possible.

5 likes

Yes, I now see why it’s not worth it. Thanks Bart and Jeff!

4 likes